Re:
by coldtea on Thursday September 11, 2014 @05:47PM
(#8305352)
>What we want from Apple isn't new technology. We want human warmth—a possibility of living a more fulfilled, meaningful life
Perhaps you shouldn't go looking for it in a tech/consumer electronic company then?
Apple was never about "living a more fulfilled, meaningful life", which is something you can even do without any smartphones or even computers in your households...
>A larger screen size alone is a weak proposition for the company's flagship product. It's derivative of existing products and doesn't say anything differentiated from its competition.
So? Apple has always been about iterating and refining -- with the occasional new type of product (iPod, iPhone, iPad, MBA, Apple TV, Apple Watch, etc thrown in every 4-5 years or so).
Most iPod, iPhone, etc releases have had small iterative differences from the previous generation.
>The fact that it also contradicts Steve Job's original intent for the iPhone, "No one is going to buy a big phone", squelches the voice of the product and makes it come across muddled and confused.
Again, so? Jobs said many things, including that they'd never get into market X (e.g books, because "people don't read anymore") and then Apple went ahead and did it. And, of course, he also changed course when his team or the market convinced him otherwise, despite being adamant against something at first.
>The trouble now is that the iPhone 6 must depend on its host of secondary features to make the sale (...) Instead of: Apple: We have the perfect product that does X. You: OH MY GOD, I NEED THIS.
Some people have this magical unicorn idea in their mind that each time Apple presents some new iPhone people salivate and drop down for its advancements -- and that this time "it didn't happen", but in reality it just gets better and better iteratively.
That actually has been the case with EACH AND EVERY subsequent iPhone release. People and articles said the same things for 3G, the 4, the 4S, the 5, etc.
Heck, people even said that about the original iPhone, that they expected more, ain't gonna fly etc. Or even the original iPod "No wireless, less space than a nomad, lame".
>With Steve Jobs, there was no fear. There was an unassailable, almost divine level of confidence that he had something you will love. We had a crisp, singular exactness to why we'll be marching to the Apple Store after the keynote and buying that phone.
BS mystical thinking, and probably never having followed the original scene that well...
(The following fake-Jobs presentation is good though).
Perhaps you shouldn't go looking for it in a tech/consumer electronic company then?
Apple was never about "living a more fulfilled, meaningful life", which is something you can even do without any smartphones or even computers in your households...
>A larger screen size alone is a weak proposition for the company's flagship product. It's derivative of existing products and doesn't say anything differentiated from its competition.
So? Apple has always been about iterating and refining -- with the occasional new type of product (iPod, iPhone, iPad, MBA, Apple TV, Apple Watch, etc thrown in every 4-5 years or so).
Most iPod, iPhone, etc releases have had small iterative differences from the previous generation.
>The fact that it also contradicts Steve Job's original intent for the iPhone, "No one is going to buy a big phone", squelches the voice of the product and makes it come across muddled and confused.
Again, so? Jobs said many things, including that they'd never get into market X (e.g books, because "people don't read anymore") and then Apple went ahead and did it. And, of course, he also changed course when his team or the market convinced him otherwise, despite being adamant against something at first.
>The trouble now is that the iPhone 6 must depend on its host of secondary features to make the sale (...) Instead of: Apple: We have the perfect product that does X. You: OH MY GOD, I NEED THIS.
Some people have this magical unicorn idea in their mind that each time Apple presents some new iPhone people salivate and drop down for its advancements -- and that this time "it didn't happen", but in reality it just gets better and better iteratively.
That actually has been the case with EACH AND EVERY subsequent iPhone release. People and articles said the same things for 3G, the 4, the 4S, the 5, etc.
Heck, people even said that about the original iPhone, that they expected more, ain't gonna fly etc. Or even the original iPod "No wireless, less space than a nomad, lame".
>With Steve Jobs, there was no fear. There was an unassailable, almost divine level of confidence that he had something you will love. We had a crisp, singular exactness to why we'll be marching to the Apple Store after the keynote and buying that phone.
BS mystical thinking, and probably never having followed the original scene that well...
(The following fake-Jobs presentation is good though).