News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by exelius on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:01AM (#8302954)
This is an example of an arbitrage opportunity. It's a necessary evil of capitalism, and unfortunately, our government has decided that free market capitalism is an appropriate system to use for health care.

Arbitrage can be explained as thus: you have an opportunity to buy $1 for $0.75. How many dollars do you buy? The correct answer is "all of them". In this case, a drug had a sale price of $3 and a market value of $150 per pill (established by its competitor), so an investor basically purchased "all of them" and resold them at a higher price.

If your goal is maximum economic efficiency, arbitrage is necessary. It allows companies to make decisions with the goal of maximizing profit (i.e. maximum economic efficiency) in moral hazard situations: if something is legal but morally dubious, if they don't do it, someone else will force them to. This is necessary because every individual has a slightly different idea of what is "right" and what is "wrong". Businesses don't have morals because they're not people. They are amoral, and arbitrage is the means by which that amorality is maintained. If a person wishes to exercise their moral calculus, they are free to do so when making investment decisions.

I don't believe that to be the case with healthcare. In my opinion, healthcare is a sector that really shouldn't operate along capitalist principles because the goal of a national healthcare system should not be to maximize economic efficiency: it should be to maximize the health and well-being of its citizens. I know that's hard to quantify, but it's certainly not quantified by the dollars spent on health care. IMO government price controls on healthcare are the only solution to the problem. I don't know how that gets implemented, but I do know that the pendulum needs to swing towards socialized medicine if we expect things to get better.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by millstone on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:42AM (#8303214)
This isn't arbitrage (there's only one market in play). It's just a straightforward instance of an Econ 101 monopoly: if a good has inelastic demand with a single seller, the seller can make more money by raising the price above its equilibrium value.

And monopolies are not economically efficient: they impose a deadweight loss. Say the drug costs $1 per pill to manufacture. There are people who would like to buy it at $20 per pill, but not any higher. This transaction is profitable, but will not take place because the price has been artificially set at $30. That's the inefficiency.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by crusso on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:27AM (#8303099)
You're ranting against free market capitalism when the problem in the article is the result of government interference in the free market.

Retrophin is using legal (government made the laws) maneuvering to prevent competitors from creating generic equivalents of the drug.

So we should throw out all of the benefits of free market capitalism: increased innovation, competition, efficiency, etc. because of cases like this that are usually caused by something distinctly apart from free market capitalism? If anything, this is an example of misguided government regulation.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by drchaos on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:49AM (#8303266)
> the problem in the article is the result of government interference in the free market.

Exactly that. This has nothing to do with free markets, it is just simple rent-seeking through abuse of regulations, which can easily be fixed by fixing (or even better abolishing) the regulations causing the problem in the first place.

In fact it is not plausible why a generics manufacturer should have to approve a substance again which has already been approved. This does not add any safety for anyone, after all Tiopronin is Tiopronin, regardless of who manufactures it.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by exelius on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:44AM (#8303235)
I'm ranting against free market capitalism because the whole point of free market capitalism is to ensure the price of a product is as close to its "free market value" as possible. For health care products, the calculation of value is inherently inaccurate because an individual places a much higher value on his/her own life than the market would.

I do agree that this is an example of misguided government regulation. The problem is that the government tried to use a capitalist solution to a societal value problem (i.e. the orphan drug laws). This created additional arbitrage opportunities. What I'm saying is that we need a serious discussion at a national level about the goals of our health care system, and the optimal means for achieving those goals.

We don't need new government regulation of health care; we need an entirely new systemic approach to health care. We've recently had a national awakening that the approach we've taken to drug abuse doesn't work, and that we were maybe trying to solve the wrong problem in the first place. We need a similar awakening on health care, though I'm doubtful it will happen until health care is out of reach to all but the wealthiest in society.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by crusso on Thursday September 11, 2014 @02:33PM (#8304272)
because an individual places a much higher value on his/her own life than the market would

That doesn't make sense. I place a much higher value on sunflower seeds than the market does, so that means I buy a ton of sunflower seeds so that I always have a bag on hand. They are cheap to me because I love them.

we need an entirely new systemic approach to health care

We agree there, but probably not in how we would do that. Most of our healthcare industry problems would benefit from more free market, not less. Remove the government structures that create unnecessary middlemen in healthcare like employers and the current insurance companies. If there were any regulation around healthcare, it should be toward opening the market up. Force doctors and hospitals to expose their prices so that consumers can wisely use their healthcare dollars.

Even within healthcare, there are segments that produce better outcomes at diminishing prices; like the cosmetic surgery and corrective vision surgery fields. As you look at those segments, they benefit from being mostly outside of the government-insurance-employer loop of spiraling costs.

Then for all the cherry picking you're trying to do with the private sector, go back and cherry pick on the problems that governments have. Governments purposefully maximize obscurity of relationships between manufacturers, lobbyists, lawmakers, and bureaucrats so that corruption becomes rampant while serving the needs of the consumer falls way behind. If government were in charge of allocating dollars for which medicines were produced, you can bet that there would be massive overproduction of some drugs and massive shortages of others that would take election cycles to correct - with the end result being that people won't get the healthcare that they're needing.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by drchaos on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:57AM (#8303310)
> the whole point of free market capitalism is to ensure the price of a product is as close to its "free market value" as possible

You forgot competition. In a healthy market, a big difference between manufacturing cost and final price is a strong incentive for competitors to enter the market and undercut prices. You can see this in practise in unregulated markets like electronics, leading to a flood of really cheap devices, for example you can get a Galaxy S4 clone on Alibaba for about $200, whereas an original S4 goes for $400 right now.

You can bet the Chinese would also do cheap generics, if the FDA would let them.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by exelius on Thursday September 11, 2014 @12:37PM (#8303568)
Right; but the pharmaceutical industry goes out of its way to avoid competition. They won't develop drugs if there is too much competition.

I understand that someone needs to pay for R&D. Unfortunately, the US government already pays for most drug R&D, but the patents get assigned to the company doing the development in all but a few rare cases.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2014 @01:58PM (#8304058)
The US gov't does not pay for most drug R&D. It pays for most of the basic science, that often leads to drug candidates, but the industry shoulder nearly 100% of the cost of getting a drug to market.

The combined, private R&D budget for biotech is ~$70B (not including VC funding). Total NIH funding (much of which is not drug focused) is ~$30B.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by innguest on Thursday September 11, 2014 @01:20PM (#8303805)
They go out of their way by lobbying, which is to say they go out of the free market scope in order to avoid competition. So you are wrong in blaming the free market for this.

And when you say 'They won't develop drugs if there is too much competition' that only means that those existing companies won't do it - and as soon as they leave the market because they don't want to compete, several entrepreneurs will step in and fill the void because they're not afraid of competing.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by TheCoelacanth on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:50AM (#8303272)
I fail to see how things would be different without government intervention. The only difference is that competitors would be prevented through trade secrets instead of patents.
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by innguest on Thursday September 11, 2014 @01:25PM (#8303839)
And because of trade secrets I can buy "generic" Coke for cheaper. Do you see now how things would be different for prescription drugs without government intervention?
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by TheCoelacanth on Thursday September 11, 2014 @02:56PM (#8304439)
You can't realistically equate the complexity involved in reverse engineering a 100 year old cola recipe to the complexity of reverse engineering a state-of-the-art pharmaceutical.
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by innguest on Friday September 12, 2014 @12:06PM (#8308783)
Those two things are both "reverse engineering some chemical substance".

Are you making the case that old substances are much easier to reverse engineer than new ones? If so, I'd like clarification on how the market age of a substance contributes to its being more complicated to figure out.

Saying something is "state-of-the-art" only means it's the best we've got. I never knew this had any bearing on the molecular complexity of these substances. Can you make that case?

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by TheCoelacanth on Friday September 12, 2014 @01:20PM (#8309176)
The set of chemical substances that could be synthesized 100 years ago is a tiny fraction of the size of the set of chemical substances that can be synthesized now. A 100 year old cola recipe almost certainly contains only naturally occurring compounds, while a brand new pharmaceutical is almost guaranteed to contain synthetic compounds.

Additionally, creating a substitute cola recipe only requires mimicking the taste and physical characteristics. When reverse engineering a pharmaceutical it's necessary to duplicate the biological effects as well, which is far more complicated.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:07AM (#8302986)
What needs to happen is a better connection between drug prices and the outcomes they produce.

The EU does not have price controls on their drugs (only in limited circumstances). What the EU does (particularly the UK and DE) is evaluate drugs based on their own metrics to determine what a reasonable price is. If a drug is priced too high, they don't cover it.

Right now the system for determining how much value a drug brings is broken (understandably since it's not easy to do). The best example I can provide is Sovaldi (used to treat hepatitis C). The manufacturer priced the drugs at $84K for a course of therapy. Insurance companies in the US screamed blood murder.

The UK, which has a system to evaluate the utility offered by drugs (called QUALY - quality-adjusted life year) approved Sovaldi without any complaints. The drug is cheaper in the UK, but not by much.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by throwaway5752 on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:24AM (#8303074)
To be fair, Solvaldi actually is cost effective from the perspective that chronic hep C results in liver transplants or death, and a course of Solvaldi knocks out hep C entirely. It was also developed in house by Gilead AFAIK (and they bore the risk of r&d, trials, etc).

edit: thanks for the correction refurb! I has actually looked at sofosbuvir on wikipedia prior to looking because I thought it was through an acquired company. I think it's still a different nature of acquisition & development vs Valeant or the putrid behavior described in this thread's link.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:27AM (#8303098)
Sovaldi was acquired by Gilead when they purchased Pharmasset for ~$11B.

As for Sovaldi's cost effectiveness, it's more complicated that looking at liver transplants. Of the millions who have HCV, only a few percent will ever need a liver transplant.

That being said, if you look at what it costs to cure a patient of HCV, Gilead's drug is much more efficacious, so the "cost per cure" is much lower than with older drugs.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by Fuxy on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:24AM (#8303069)
It makes more economic sense to cure HepC than to treat it so I would argue they made the right choice.

The american insurance companies were screaming murder because they have no way of recovering their upfront cost with people changing insurance companies all the time in the US that's not a issue for the UK and the EU.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:29AM (#8303118)
American insurance companies were screaming blood murder not because they can't recoup the upfront costs (all insurance companies benefit if HCV is eliminated), but because the cost were all upfront, not spread out over time.

US insurance companies live and die by their yearly budgets since premiums are collected upfront. If some high cost drug comes along that they didn't plan for, they could end up in the red really quick.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by exelius on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:34AM (#8303157)
The Eurpoean method only works in a single-payer system. A single-payer system effectively has price controls. At the very least the EU system is not designed to maximize profit; it's designed to maximize the benefit to the people given a fixed budget.

The biggest problem with the US' system is that consumers have to pay out of pocket for life and death decisions. How much would you pay to not die? Probably a lot; which is exactly why the US system is broken. You can't make rational market-based decisions when your health / quality of life is at stake. The value calculation is skewed, and everyone ends up paying more as a result.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:37AM (#8303180)
I agree with your comment about how the EU system works. It's a fixed budget and the gov't tries to maximize health outcomes.

I would disagree that the problem with the US system is that consumers pay out of pocket. Singapore has a system of forced savings for healthcare expenses and they have a much lower cost per person for healthcare.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by mikeash on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:36AM (#8303165)
Isn't arbitrage where a third party buys a product in one place and sells it in another, pocketing the difference? Here, we have a company just buying up competitors to stifle competition. Arbitrage would be buying the drug where it's available at $1.50 and then selling it at $30 where the $1.50 price can't be obtained. Such opportunities are generally fleeting, because the very action of arbitrage pushes the prices towards equality.

This is also not really an example of free market capitalism, unless you take an extremely laissez-faire definition of it. This is a monopoly, with a captive audience and government regulations providing a barrier to new competitors. In true free market capitalism, this would never happen because if the original company could make a profit at $1.50, then the new company's $30 price would be immediately undercut by other companies who see that they can make a profit at, say, $20, and the price will naturally fall back to something around the costs of production. Of course, you'd also probably get a lot of companies undercutting it even further by selling dangerous products, thus why these regulations are there in the first place.

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by tedks on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:18AM (#8303037)
> In my opinion, healthcare is a sector that really shouldn't operate along capitalist principles because the goal of a national healthcare system should not be to maximize economic efficiency: it should be to maximize the health and well-being of its citizens

Why should we stop at healthcare if we're deciding that health and well-being is more important than economic efficiency? Energy, transportation, and service are all industries that have huge health effects. Agriculture obviously has huge health effects. Why not socialize all of them in the name of health?

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by mikeash on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:24AM (#8303071)
We do socialize all of those, to lesser or greater extents.
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by tedks on Thursday September 11, 2014 @12:04PM (#8303355)
This article mentions price controls. There are tax benefits to using green electricity/cars versus polluting electricity/cars, but should gas cars be price-controlled up and electric cars price-controlled down? Should Tesla be made to accept only a set amount of profit as a measure of increasing the average health faster than it would otherwise?

Actually, Tesla is a great example of how the health > economic efficiency question is answered decisively in favor of economic efficiency (or at least, profit for existing stakeholders). If governments cared about health more than profits, Tesla would never be barred from selling in a single state.

If you start thinking that health and welfare are more important that economic efficiency, I think the vast majority of the current economic policy goes out the window. The IMF certainly shouldn't be advising struggling countries to cut education and healthcare first if health is truly more important that economic efficiency. If economic efficiency were truly second to health, the world should look very different. Would that really be better?

Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by toomuchtodo on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:27AM (#8303100)
I regret having only one upvote for you.
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by mikeash on Thursday September 11, 2014 @11:37AM (#8303178)
If only HN were a true free market, then you could buy more!
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by tedks on Thursday September 11, 2014 @12:06PM (#8303382)
Why stop at upvotes? If hacker news were a truly free market, you should be able to buy any action the site supports over its database, and for a higher price, any operation the database itself supports. If Hacker News really cared about economic efficiency more than things like "insight" and "good discussion," we could buy shadowbans, changes to vote weights, and edits to comments or post titles.
Re:The Most Unconscionable Drug Price Hike I Have Yet Seen by toomuchtodo on Thursday September 11, 2014 @12:12PM (#8303417)
Your post reminded me of "Citizens United".