Bananas are heavily chemically treated with ethylene, an inert gas which causes plants to ripen faster and is harmless to humans.
(Fun fact: It's why bananas are never put next to other fruit in the supermarket, because they will cause other fruit to ripen and spoil faster.)
Bananas also haven't been a monoculture since day 1 either - but have been developed that way through centuries of selective breeding. The article outlines the monoculture problem quite well, but doesn't really mention that it's because the consumable plant [mostly] only reproduces asexually.
What's wrong with using tiny stickers on fruit for 'branding'?
Indeed, with food production, the evidence and points of view are always very diverse and nuanced. It's a complex subject--endless, really.
Here's a clip about banana chemical treatment...
> "...Zemurray finally addressed the problem. He found a solution, which he called 'Bordeaux Mixture' and that combined copper sulphate, water, and lime. Zemurray's experts cautioned him against its overuse but he had it pumped on the plantations in increasing quantity. It was a cocktail with quite a pleasant name, but the giveaway was in the title of those employed to spray and pump it: veneneros, or for want of a better translation, 'poisoners'
I would be very interested to find out if the industry decreased the pesticide/fungicide load since this was documented. I'm quoting secondhand here, Chapman notes in the 2007 book
> Of the world's food crops, the banana is the most chemically treated (so we depend on its skin's ability to prevent disease)
The story of marketing bananas is such a strange one. The 'Father of Public Relations', Edward Bernays, was heavily involved. There isn't a compelling dietary reason to eat bananas (expect, I suppose, if it's the only thing you've got). They resorted to the same marketing tactics that were used to sell cigarettes.
> "Samuel Crowther...looking back on nearly twenty years later on these early days of United Fruit in his book The Romance and Rise of the American Tropics, what was being discovered was that 'demand is a thing which must be created" (51)
Without getting into too much of a discussion about health and diet... I find that the heuristic that "anything new is bad" seems to work pretty well with food. Trans fats, high fructose corn syrup, factory farms, etc.
The history of bananas shows that the production and demand for the fruit is both very new and completely artificial.
Again, please feel free to draw your own conclusions. The only point to make here is that I found the reading surprisingly fascinating -- a banana is not just a banana.
Not all "chemicals" are evil.
A while ago Monsanto ran a series of condescending ads whose tagline was "without chemicals life itself would be impossible"
http://peterfeld.tumblr.com/post/51503279414/monsanto-ad-197...
Bananas are one of the oldest agricultural crops known to man (8000 BC) - there's no reason to "go bananas" about them.
There was demand for bananas before, but mostly as a local crop.
Here is some actual data from 2009, with analysis for Brazil by a proper agency (ANVISA's PARA, Project for Analysis of Agrotoxic Residue in Food):
http://portal.anvisa.gov.br/wps/wcm/connect/1424b98041ebbfb7...
It's in Portuguese, but you can find a nice color table in page 7 with fruit and vegetable names (rows) and states (columns) providing an idea (red == bad).
Bananas do better than pretty much anything else tested there.
Not even close. Craftsman's marks -- the original trademarks -- are pretty much the original form of branding, and predate banana stickers by by probably on the order of a couple thousand years.
The thumbnail summary: bananas only started being widely consumed in the 1960s because of heavy marketing efforts by Central American railroad builders (they had to do something with the land along the sides of the newly built railroads, and bananas happened to fit).
They are heavily chemically treated, more than any other fruit. They've been a monoculture almost since Day 1.
Oh, another fun fact, those little stickers on bananas? They were one of the first examples of 'branding'
I didn't find this article all that well written or informative. I recommend Chapman's Bananas: How the United Fruit Company Shaped the World
I also happened to read John McPhee's Oranges at the same time. The contrast between the orange (an ancient fruit, widely consumed, hardy, with a rich literary tradition) and the banana is stark.
Both books, by the way, are great little studies in technology business. Techno-optimism, marketing, PR, globalization, manic CEOs; it's all there.