So does that mean you think motorcycles should have access to the sidewalks, and pedestrians should be able to walk in the street?
But to more bluntly answer your question: actually, yes, at least sometimes. Though I would instead phrase it as erasing the distinction between sidewalks and streets: http://nacto.org/usdg/commercial-shared-street/ This kind of streetscape is common in Europe and Asia, but much less so in the States.
Why is that controversial or problematic? I don't understand the shitty entitled attitude of bikers honestly. I'm not only advocating for something that's safer, more pleasant and more convenient for them, but I'm willing to put my wallet to work and inconvenience myself to support it.
All I'm getting is flak over it and the responses to it are doing little to dissuade me of my already negative opinion of cyclists as a population.