Re:Stanford engineer aims to connect the world with ant-size...
by farmerjack on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @03:25PM
(#8298511)
Who is saying that the analogously named models are equivalent the analogs themselves? Analogous terminology and metaphors exist so that people can ease themselves into a deeper understanding of a subject. I agree that some people can incorrectly draw grand conclusions from a simple name, but that doesn't mean the people who use these "things" with these "names" only understand their mechanisms on a superficial level. Seriously, good luck explaining any model without introducing an analog that we, as humans, can relate with.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Stanford engineer aims to connect the world with ant-size...
by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 11, 2014 @06:39AM
(#8301799)
Sure, I'm not saying analogies are the problem. They're not, we need them, they're important parts of our cognition.
My point was twofold: a/ beware inference from surface analogies, always strive to understand where the border between similar and different properties lie, and b/ it does happen. People do draw conclusions and build their understanding on superficial analogies in a systematic way. That's why I mentioned the anecdote of CS students I know. I've seen it in real life. Also known as cargo-culting, it's unfortunately not a rare phenomenon.
Also, I'm not the CDDDDARP ((cddddar this-comment)-poster), but I hazard a guess that he "felt sort of foolish" because he discovered he accidentally did some inferring from surface analogies and ended up disappointed.