News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poor UI Design Can Kill – Air Inter Flight 148, a Harsh L... by userbinator on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:04AM (#8296123)
I think the concept you're referring to is self-indicating, or in this case the lack thereof. A much more commonplace example that comes to mind is volume control knobs on things like stereo amps; the "old style" had a knob directly connected to the potentiometer controlling the volume, so it was self-indicating and at a glance (or even just by feel if the pointer is tactile) you could see what position it was set to. Now it seems fashionable to use knobs that don't have any markings and will spin continuously, meaning that you have to look at the display to see what the setting is.

To me it sounds like a cost-cutting measure - to have controls that move, there has to be an actuator in them, which makes it more expensive. My stereo which has self-indicating volume knobs actually contains a small motor that rotates them when I use the remote control.

Re:Poor UI Design Can Kill – Air Inter Flight 148, a Harsh L... by omegant on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:44AM (#8296256)
In airliners without flight by wire, the levers move because the automatic system it's engaged directly to them. With fly by wire you have to replicate that system, at least with the throttle levers. I guess that a servo motor and a control-indication circuit it's not the cost that concerns Airbus. It's all the chain of costs related to changing the flight philosophy. In the case of the sidestick you could link them mechanically, with a disconnect lever to isolate them.
Re:Poor UI Design Can Kill – Air Inter Flight 148, a Harsh L... by mnarayan01 on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @01:33PM (#8297776)
Concerns about errors is another reason they might not do this: extreme corner cases and/or wear and tear might result in incorrect feedback. This would be at least roughly equivalent to the display meters displaying the wrong values; obviously a horribly bad occurrence.