Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West...
by notahacker on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:42PM
(#8287489)
I'd agree that the "ideal size of a state" is pretty fundamental to the debate but don't see much of an argument for independence improving matters in the original post
I'd argue that where is Scotland's economic power base going to come from, and what sort of economic freedom will they actually get[1] is a much more fundamental, long term issue than the present set of Westminster politicians being uninspiring careerist with a lack of radical ideas, which this article discusses at great length. For better or worse a similarly sized and distributed UK electorate produced much more conviction politics and polarisation in the 70s and 80s. As for the consensus politics, the only guaranteed outcome of the referendum is that 40-49% of the electorate is going to be bitterly disappointed.
Even the arcane philosophical question of the present level of devolution waters down the allegedly-obsolete Westphalian system whereas a fully independent Scotland freed from any Westminster tinkering reestablishes it[2] is open for debate.
[1]The only problem I have with the debate about whether Scotland will be economically better off is that neither side is willing to openly admit the most likely outcome of post-independence negotiations (Holyrood ceding rather a lot of oil revenue and fiscal handcuffs for formal currency union in the form of token representation on the Bank of England's committees)
[2]The actual Westphalian treaty, amongst other things, established the formal independence of the Netherlands and Switzerland from larger empires
I'd argue that where is Scotland's economic power base going to come from, and what sort of economic freedom will they actually get[1] is a much more fundamental, long term issue than the present set of Westminster politicians being uninspiring careerist with a lack of radical ideas, which this article discusses at great length. For better or worse a similarly sized and distributed UK electorate produced much more conviction politics and polarisation in the 70s and 80s. As for the consensus politics, the only guaranteed outcome of the referendum is that 40-49% of the electorate is going to be bitterly disappointed.
Even the arcane philosophical question of the present level of devolution waters down the allegedly-obsolete Westphalian system whereas a fully independent Scotland freed from any Westminster tinkering reestablishes it[2] is open for debate.
[1]The only problem I have with the debate about whether Scotland will be economically better off is that neither side is willing to openly admit the most likely outcome of post-independence negotiations (Holyrood ceding rather a lot of oil revenue and fiscal handcuffs for formal currency union in the form of token representation on the Bank of England's committees)
[2]The actual Westphalian treaty, amongst other things, established the formal independence of the Netherlands and Switzerland from larger empires