I have plenty of graduate Irish friends, almost all of whom live and work in the UK or America, they care about independence in spite of the costs. A massive majority of Scots don't, because Scotland's place in the UK is not one of conquered subject nation and thus her constitutional arrangement is much better.
More interesting on the CTA is that it would involve signing up to many of the immigration policies rUK and Ireland have agreed to as part of that deal - that contradicts the more open immigration policy the SNP are selling as part of their pitch (which also includes the CTA).
The UK is in the EU - a new country is being formed, that country is not in the EU.
The Yes proponents appear to be answering all the tricky questions with "{smiling and waving hands} we're sure it'll work out in our favour".
I'm waiting for HM the Queen to dissolve her Scottish parliament and put Salmond in the Tower! That'd spice things up a bit.
But that's a separate issue about Scotland joining full stop, rather than the terms on which they'd join. I suspect if Catalonia declared independence then the most sensible starting point for their EU membership is what covers them already (that is Spain's position). No-one really benefits from a position where unnecessary change and uncertainty is pushed onto newly formed countries.
I agree that the yes campaign's approach to difficult issues seems to be essentially "don't worry your pretty little heads about it, it'll all be fine, we've got the oil".
Short version: if it's a yes vote, it's going to be a big ol' mess for a while.
>"My broader point stands: there is a precedent for a constituent nation peacefully leaving the UK within the past century." //
Has he forgotten that the EU started about 30 years after this? That seems the main reason that this situation is completely different - the geopolitical landscape has changed entirely, ignoring that seems rather strange.
Currently we enjoy the CTA, so no obvious border controls with Eire. But UK + Eire are not in the Schengen area. EU have decided that all new countries will be in the Schengen area, Scotland thus will not be able to be in the CTA without the rUK (and Eire) effectively accepting the Schengen Agreement. Now I may have misjudged the current political temperature but with the rise of UKIP I can't see the rUK voting to relax immigration policy.
If Scotland don't get in to Europe presumably rUK will be required to maintain border controls whether we acceded to the Schengen Agreement or not.
Peacefully?
He does at least mention the 2 year war of independence, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_War_of_Independence. There was a lot of violence besides, I'm sure the PLA/INLA/[provisional] IRA and the likes haven't been forgotten but those considerations probably aren't relevant _what with all the differences between the situations_.
The lesson to learn from Eire is probably that if a unified region vote No then don't try and keep them as part of the Union. But that doesn't really work, if there's a land border it makes sense (Borders or D&G). Also for the islands, if Orkney and Shetland voted No, then there's far less chance that rest-of-Scotland will form a navy and start attacking them as their first action? The geography is different, the age is different, the politics are different, the modes of government are different, we're 100 years further away from feudalism for starters.
It's worth making the comparison but concluding the situations are the same seems disingenuous at best.