News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by icebraining on Monday September 08, 2014 @10:06AM (#8284759)
It's not a "market differentiator". If a company can't develop that "feature", they just won't be able to release their driverless cars.
Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by mrec on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:41AM (#8285372)
It's not a binary checkbox feature, though. I doubt any implementation will make it utterly impossible to hit a pedestrian - and that's fine, as long as they do better than meatbag drivers. A better detection/avoidance implementation is absolutely a differentiator, mostly via lower insurance premiums for operators.
Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by JoeAltmaier on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:48AM (#8285408)
That's not clear, in our litigenous society. I hit a pedestrian: I get in trouble. A driverless car hits a pedestrian: all driverless cars (of that manufacturer) are potentially 'at fault' and recalled. Its definitely a different bar to pass.
Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by josho on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:03PM (#8287580)
That's interesting. A computer hits a pedestrian, then presumably the algorithms are updated and the probability of that scenario playing out again drops to 0. While A human hits a pedestrian, and that scenario is likely to never occur for that driver again, but for all other drivers the probability remains the same.
Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by krapp on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:08PM (#8287595)
Although you technically may be right (depending on how easy 'updating the algorithm' turns out to be - it being as easy as updating an app seems a bit on the crazy side to me) I don't know that the likelihood for all human drivers of hitting a pedestrian is necessarily high, though.

It exists, obviously, but I think human drivers already come with the "don't hit pedestrians" firmware installed, and it mostly seems to work.

To me it won't be demonstrable that driverless cars are vastly superior until there are a decent number of them on the streets, mixing it up with traffic in all kinds of weather, dealing with unexpected hazards and inaccurate maps, for an extended period of time.

Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by icebraining on Monday September 08, 2014 @07:02PM (#8287799)
depending on how easy 'updating the algorithm' turns out to be - it being as easy as updating an app seems a bit on the crazy side to me

Tesla is already updating the firmware of their cars over-the-air[1]. It seems likely that driverless cars will have the same feature.

[1] http://www.theverge.com/2012/9/24/3385506/tesla-model-s-over...

Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by krapp on Monday September 08, 2014 @07:08PM (#8287818)
Fair enough - just crazy enough to work, maybe.

(but still crazy.)

Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by mrec on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:49PM (#8286475)
But recalls happen already, for all sorts of reasons. They're expensive, and they can have a big impact on a manufacturer's reputation, but they don't mean that nobody can sell a car in the first place.
Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by robbrown451 on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:44AM (#8285384)
It's not a black and white thing. No driverless car, nor human driver, can claim to 100% avoid accidents, even those that are theoretically avoidable. But some can be better/safer than others.

Most likely, though, the way competition will play out around this issue is how conservative the decisions the vehicle makes will be. So a "lesser" vehicle might come to a complete stop at a crosswalk, while a better one (as well as any reasonable human driver) might be able to calculate that it can safely drive on through because that pedestrian is well way out of the way. Both vehicles can be equally safe, but one gets you to your destination a lot faster because it is better at accurately estimating collision risk, so it doesn't have to compensate by sacrificing timeliness.

Competition is important.

Re:Google Driverless Car – The Obstacle Detection Unit by josho on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:16PM (#8287629)
Herein lies why I can't wait for driverless cars. Cars are supposed to stop while a pedestrian is in an intersection, no matter if the pedestrian has already passed the car and is a 'safe distance away'. The reason is by stopping you are signalling to other drivers that there may be a pedestrian in the intersection. Just in case the other drivers don't see the pedestrian for some reason.

I agree with your point however, that competition is important on performance elements like the quality of the drive.