Re:Idea Market is a crowd-sourced marketplace to take on pro...
by vjanma on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:19AM
(#8284533)
Hello, co-founder of IdeaMarket here. Would love to hear HN's feedback and ways to improve. Also can answer any questions.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Idea Market is a crowd-sourced marketplace to take on pro...
by tomp on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:57AM
(#8284713)
I'm not sure if it's a problem with my browser/connection or a bug on your side, but I cannot create an account (using the sign-up form, not using an external service). After I click "Create Account", it seems that there is an 500 error in the POST request.
Re:Idea Market is a crowd-sourced marketplace to take on pro...
by vjanma on Monday September 08, 2014 @10:45AM
(#8285018)
I am not sure it this is related to our account quota issue, which is fixed. Can you try now please?
Re:Idea Market is a crowd-sourced marketplace to take on pro...
by caio1982 on Monday September 08, 2014 @10:58AM
(#8285100)
Please disregard if this is not totally important for a landing page, but I missed very much a "who we are" section. Or anything that's similar to an about page. That may be in the video I guess, but since I can't watch it in the place I'm right now...
Re:Idea Market is a crowd-sourced marketplace to take on pro...
by 10QR7s041s1Zc on Monday September 08, 2014 @10:06AM
(#8284758)
Signup is required to see the various challenges - this sucks.
Also, the website appears to require Javascript (so noscript users are forced to whitelist the website). You're far from the only one to have this issue though.
Re:Idea Market is a crowd-sourced marketplace to take on pro...
by vjanma on Monday September 08, 2014 @10:47AM
(#8285026)
You don't have to signup to see various challenges.
You can scroll down to the bottom of this page: http://ideamarket.com/founders.html
It does require Javascript though :-|
Re:Idea Market is a crowd-sourced marketplace to take on pro...
by 10QR7s041s1Zc on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:12AM
(#8285181)
Correct, my apologies.<br />
About the JS stuff: sorry if I sounded bitter - I guess it's perfectly acceptable, business-wise, to not support non-JS users given the fact that they are probably a tiny minority of users. I just wish more people would consider us noscript paranoid users :-)<br />
As for the website, it is pretty good - I like the idea of having projects for which the investment is already available. I don't like the name that much though - it suggests that ideas are something that have inherent values and that you can sell. In my mind, ideas have no value whatsoever: when you have an idea, you can bet lots of other people already had it too. Realization is what matters.<br />
Finally, on a more personnal note, I dislike the big-ass chair picture on the front page - it seems uncorelated to the platform itself. Then again, that's just me :-)