News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moto 360 review – Beautiful outside, ugly inside by nkozyra on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:01AM (#8284463)
I would put very big money on smart watches not failing.

What we're seeing now is something we see often in newish technologies - we take an existing technology and attempt to shoehorn it into another.

A smartwatch should not be an analog to a phone. It also probably shouldn't be a watch. But as happens so often, we say "put phone plus watch = product?"

There's very little here that's exploiting the advantages of a wearable on the arm. When wearables start exploiting their physical advantages, they'll stop being cool tech toys and start being useful.

Re:Moto 360 review – Beautiful outside, ugly inside by VLM on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:37AM (#8284611)
"we take an existing technology and attempt to shoehorn it into another."

Not financially, which is a HUGE problem for smart watches.

I'm considered an unamerican weirdo crazy, at least in part, because I dropped like four hundred bucks on a smart phone and pay only $22/month just for service, instead of paying $100 on a two year contract like a real American, who can just barely afford a $100/month callphone bill but could never financially survive a single one time $400 expense.

These watch guys think they're going to sell $300 one time expense watches to a people who as a group have already proven they would rather pay loan shark interest rates rather than pony up a couple hundred bucks to buy their phone. This is a recipe for disaster.

The only way smart watches can possibly survive is by being bundled into a contract with AT&T or whoever, say an extra $50 a month for two years on their existing contract which would be a modest 150% APR loanshark-grade loan. You "know" the consumers are not going to be able to pony up $300 cash because they're already self selected as loanshark victims.

Re:Moto 360 review – Beautiful outside, ugly inside by hyp0 on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:10AM (#8284500)
Health monitoring stuff is in that category. It could become a thing in itself, especially if other sensors are added. eg blood sugar, not just for diabetics, but dieting, sport, concentration. general health.
Re:Moto 360 review – Beautiful outside, ugly inside by nkozyra on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:56AM (#8285474)
Absolutely. But first gen smartwatches have barely-functioning sleep and step monitors. That's not worth $250.

Another huge problem with the self-quantification trend is there isn't much emphasis on doing stuff with that data. There's a fervor about knowing about yourself, but a large gap in utilizing that data.

Smart watches could very well fill that role. A nice first step would be to stop calling them smart watches. Wearables isn't much better.

Re:Moto 360 review – Beautiful outside, ugly inside by hyp0 on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:52PM (#8287764)
yes, it's very plausible as a thing in itself. They can succeed without replacing smartphones.

Computers keep shrinking, from mainframes to desktops, laptops, smartphones. I'm curious about the next smaller form-factor, and argue it's not watches, but glasses. That was the claim I meant to make.

Re:Moto 360 review – Beautiful outside, ugly inside by MatthiasP on Monday September 08, 2014 @10:04AM (#8284746)
Exactly. Out of all the things a smartwatch could do, only health tracking is something that your smartphone can't do. The successful smartwatch will not be a little window to your smartphone, but a high quality health tracker that integrates perfectly with your phone and ALSO shows you the time and notifications.