Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ...
by downandout on Sunday September 07, 2014 @07:11PM
(#8282762)
In general in order to break the law you must have a warrant. For example, a cop entering private property without a warrant or probable cause is nothing more than a trespasser. These agents likely violated the CFAA by doing what they did. Because they didn't have a warrant, IMO it probably constitutes an illegal search, but the courts may well have a very different opinion. Regardless of which side loses this argument, this will likely find its way to the appellate courts and possibly the Supreme court, as it seems to be an unanswered question of great importance.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ...
by maxerickson on Sunday September 07, 2014 @08:28PM
(#8282924)
From the CFAA:
(f) This section does not prohibit any lawfully authorized investigative, protective, or intelligence activity of a law enforcement agency of the United States, a State, or a political subdivision of a State, or of an intelligence agency of the United States.
I'm not sure what "lawfully authorized" means there, but my current belief is that one form of it is permission from the Attorney General.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ...
by downandout on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:19PM
(#8283301)
But I wonder if computer hacking (which this likely would fall under) can be "lawfully authorized" outside the confines of a search warrant. The Attorney General could order the FBI to break into the computers of a hedge fund suspected of insider trading, but that clearly wouldn't be lawful unless authorized via search warrant. This is very similar.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ...
by maxerickson on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:38PM
(#8283342)
Well, I don't think they broke into the computer. But I guess my point was more that the CFAA doesn't have any answers, you have to figure out the scope of the authority possessed by the Department of Justice.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ...
by billyhoffman on Sunday September 07, 2014 @09:31PM
(#8283075)
+1. I wasn't aware this clause existed in the CFAA.