Re:Why Flunking Exams Is Actually a Good Thing
by WalterBright on Friday September 05, 2014 @05:32PM
(#8276429)
You're right that understanding implies some level of memorization. But memorization does not imply any understanding, any more than a textbook "understands" anything.
You get from students what you test for. Testing "what is the formula relating volts vs resistance vs current" means the student can regurgitate V=IR. Understanding what that formula means is something else entirely.
Re:Why Flunking Exams Is Actually a Good Thing
by noobermin on Friday September 05, 2014 @06:01PM
(#8276550)
I used to think I could get by without committing much to memory, but I find that I am more efficient if I add more to memory than I was willing to in undergrad.
Nonetheless, you are right to persecute those who emphasize memorization over understanding, formula plugging over understanding what a formula means because that seems to be the direction of education that is most threatening nowadays. And yes, memorization is easier than understanding.
I am a graduate student in Physics, and admittedly not in Caltech or one of it's peers, but I find that "memorization" (or, as I would put it, familiarity) is very important for understanding. I can't spend my time looking up formulae, I have to be able to just pull it out, or visualize it, at least. As the content I work with becomes more complex, I need to have more and more of the things I'm working on as part of my knowledge, ie., I need to memorize. If it isn't in my head, how can I put it all together?