News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by otakucode on Friday September 05, 2014 @02:54PM (#8275621)
One might be persuaded to believe that IT is actually something that provides a monetarily significant benefit to an organization... but we know that can't be true. Just because every iota of every business flows through computers and even minor software projects can multiply the productivity of employees by an order of magnitude, that doesn't mean management should be expected to value IT in such a way that they actually are willing to pay significant amounts for it!
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by lukasm on Friday September 05, 2014 @03:16PM (#8275750)
I worked for a while for Morgan Stanley and have 20 friends that work in finance.

They pay a lot for IT. Good hacker can make 300k, but the main problem that big banks have is complexity. Years of M&A, 20 systems that do the same. Simply paying more is not a solution.

Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by VonGuard on Friday September 05, 2014 @03:20PM (#8275777)
Yup. You like supporting COBOL? FORTRAN? How about some PL/1 running on AIX or something equally as byzantine... M&A can ruin your will to live.
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by valarauca1 on Friday September 05, 2014 @04:45PM (#8276192)
Your modern z/OS mainframes are just unix.

The problem is the average IBMer will not know how to secure your zOS server. If you ask them how to configure, or how to manage files they'll tell you their aren't any. This is simply amazing double speak because they are, and are not correct. When you first log into this systems you see the old zOS stuff, which looks and feels like MTS system360-67M/70 (its a long story). All your files are data sets, which aren't files, see MTS didn't have files, it had data sets.

But it isn't. Its just a mainframe layer running on AIX. Its called something dumb like encom, unicom, in MTS . That brings you into proper unix mode. Which you may think is running inside MTS, but it isn't. MTS is running inside AIX. Because keeping MTS up to date with modern hardware would be impossible. So we just trick it into thinking its processor is running at the Plank frequency. Not 200 PowerPC chips or what ever IBM shoves in these things today.

Then your in a standard unix environment. If you attack these things from the outside (and get in), you'll see and feel what looks like a BSD/SysV (ish) system. Because that's what it is. Its a unix system.

But nobody configures this crap because the mainframe dudes can just say, "Oh no there are no files on a mainframe, just data sets, they're different." But if I steal a data set in unix mode, its a file. So no, your wrong.

Nobody really goes into Unix mode half the time. They just care about keeping the system360 stuff working. Nobody cares about security because "Its a mainframe, they don't have security issues." Well they do, just like every other unix box on the planet. But unlike every other unix box we pretend they don't need security.

Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by marktangotango on Friday September 05, 2014 @09:22PM (#8277099)
I don' quiet buy your assertion that z/os is an emulation layer over AIX. When I used to while away the days poking around on a z/os machine, it was not that cut and dry. I couldn't just access a dataset from the shell, and the mainframe permissions model was pretty effective at locking down what I could get too. Do you have any references to back that ie an IBM red book?
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by blincoln on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:36AM (#8281433)
I was thinking the same thing - I knew that z-series mainframes could run Unix, but I didn't think they always did - but it looks like valarauca is correct (assuming this Wikipedia article is reasonably accurate: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UNIX_System_Services). Wow, that's a whole new attack vector I'm going to have to look into now. Exciting! Thanks valarauca!
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by valarauca1 on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:14PM (#8285581)
Defcon21 there was an hour long talk. (I'm not 100% sure it was 21, could have been 20).

I look at MTS on a nearly a weekly basis. I want to say z/OS's mainframe OS is based on MTS. I don't know this for sure.

This is how I arrived at this conclusion:

(This is all ancient ~6-8 years Pre-Unix System 1)

See the big draw of of the System360 was Michigan University shoe horned in memory visualization (which allowed for concurrent time shared processing). This was released as the System360-67M (M for Michigan), these things exploded off the shelves. IBM received roughly 100 orders for these systems, not requests to lease time, but cash in hand gimme that.

They rolled out the System360-70 which was just the System360-67M, but under a different name. These are going to ship with TSS/360 (Time Sharing System 360). But ya know it never got done in time, and UofM had already finished MTS. Which did explode.

Also OS/360 was batched based. You couldn't have multi-user, multi-process. Which famously modern System360 emulation can do. So who knows.

I honestly don't know. But I'm 90% sure z/OS is just AIX with MTS in some kind of BSD-esque jail. I think MTS is open-ish sourced. It had a big community up until it was mothballed universally in the mid to late 90's.

:.:.:

I certainly can't afford a z/OS system to sit around and pentest myself :P

:.:.:

Also as I stated nobody configures the security of the underlying unix on IBM mainframes. So they maybe fairly easy to own.

Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by hvs on Friday September 05, 2014 @11:36PM (#8277412)
I think he is saying that a lot of these companies have a mainframe emulator running z/OS on unix rather than a true mainframe. I'm not sure if that's true or not, but I believe that's why he is saying you can attack from the unix side.

z/OS itself is most certainly not an emulation layer over AIX. It's a complex operating system with 50 years of history behind it.

Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by opendais on Friday September 05, 2014 @03:31PM (#8275841)
Bah, at least PL/1 is still maintained by IBM.

Come back when the language you are running on that AIX system is completely dead since before 1990 and there is no online documentation for it. ;)

Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by VonGuard on Friday September 05, 2014 @03:44PM (#8275909)
ALGOL
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by opendais on Friday September 05, 2014 @03:51PM (#8275937)
Fair enough :)
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by _delirium on Friday September 05, 2014 @08:03PM (#8276932)
Could be personal preference, but that actually sounds more fun than a lot of things in tech. Software archaeology on ancient and possibly broken systems? Probably has lots of annoying parts, but also sounds pretty interesting. Is it really less annoying to do "modern" work, like learning the Nth new Javascript framework, dealing with piles of Chef scripts, extending Enterprise C++ codebases, spending weeks testing browser compatibility, etc.?
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by blincoln on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:48AM (#8281480)
My experience is that it's a lot less fun in practice than it is in theory. Uncommented spaghetti COBOL code is about as hard to reverse-engineer as an x86 disassembler dump done without debug symbols, IMO.
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by cdr on Friday September 05, 2014 @06:59PM (#8276746)
I used to know someone making a pretty good living doing COBOL for banks. Some people really do enjoy that sort of thing. Also a bonus of less (or even positive) age discrimination, since he was an older guy.
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by Retric on Friday September 05, 2014 @06:12PM (#8276585)
Failing to migrate after a M&A is failure to invest in IT. It's a stupid, short sited, and expensive failure, but good luck finding banks willing to pay for it.
Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by GVIrish on Friday September 05, 2014 @07:14PM (#8276795)
Banks will only become willing to pay after experiencing expensive, massive disasters like what JPMorgan is experiencing. Maybe.

Migrating and/or killing large legacy enterprise applications is monstrously expensive, so the decision makers often decide against it. Relatively speaking, there haven't been enough very large companies that have been burned by that sort of decision, so executives at these companies (and the government) are less likely to see how badly it can go.

Then there's the very real challenge of justifying a big IT spend on retiring legacy applications to the shareholders. And the high chances of large enterprise IT projects going wildly over budget.

As much as we like to point the finger at the c-suite guys who keep doubling down on technical debt until there's a disaster, it's not an easy to make the case for paying to fix the problem. At least not until there are plenty of negative case studies out there like this one.

Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by at-fates-hands on Friday September 05, 2014 @07:17PM (#8276806)
>>> that doesn't mean management should be expected to value IT in such a way that they actually are willing to pay significant amounts for it!

I was at one large financial company similar to JPMo and every time the development team came up with a good idea, it was met with a laundry list of requirements we had to meet in order to show positive ROI over a very short time period. Not sure if they did to discourage us from trying to help processes and development, or they really believed redesigning some parts of their network architecture could be done in a month or two.

Either way, it was quite frustrating to say the least, and after a few gallant attempts to get something going, most of the younger developers just opted out and left. I saw the writing on the wall and was in the second wave of people who finally gave up and moved on.

Re:JPMorgan Suffered Exodus of Tech Talent Before Breach by ... by wheaties on Friday September 05, 2014 @10:41PM (#8277298)
JP pays programmers very well. In fact, it's very good for the counties in which those programmers are employed. Well, that is, if they were in a money center. Costs centers, like security and infrastructure, those places they minimize the costs! Part of minimizing costs is all about not paying for things that aren't expressly needed or killing programs that might make sense but cost too much.

I worked there for half a year before quitting and going back to a start up. Nice people but only the people at the top seem to have a clue as to what to fix and they, themselves, can only focus on so many things at once.