Now, of course, if it's such a hot startup that investors are cramming to get into a round, it probably less of a dilemma. But that might not always be the case.
The reality is that the decision is probably never between the future of the company and honoring your promises. It would be irrational for an early investor to allow the company to die in order to preserve their percentage stake in a zeroed-out investment.
The behavior contemplated in this blog post isn't that dilemma. It's "this conversation with early investors is going to be sticky, and will involve some form of concession to them --- therefore, we're going to exploit their lack of leverage and bulldoze through them." That's unethical. It's not a tragic dilemma. It's being presented with an opportunity to harm someone for your own convenience, and all that's asked of you as a human is to simply not do that.
What I have in mind as the dilemma is exactly the fact that is is rational for the early investor to accept the terms of the latter round, which is why they are likely to get screwed. The dilemma of the founder, to me, seems to be whether (1) to go along with whatever terms the latter investors propose, even though you know it's not fair to the early investors, because you know that it's rational for the early investor to accept them, or (2) to stick out with the early investors and only accept further investment provided they honour your agreement (and not try to strong-arm the early investor in giving up their rights), even though it's not rational for you (the founder) or your company to do so (however, it's rational for you+early investor).
It's similar to the story that was on HN earlier - founders that had great exists had rewarded their employees with additional equity/cash, even though they were neither rationally nor legally bound to do it - but they did it anyways, because it was fair / the right thing to do.
That's the sort of dilemmas I'm talking about, and I believe the original article is talking about.
The rationality of ethics depends on everyone believing they are part of a multi-round game.
Hint: even if you think you are playing a single round game, you probably aren't.
How could it be otherwise? Virtually nobody is in a position to casually and efficiently use the courts to enforce contract terms.
A contract documents a promise. Promises must be kept.
Ethics have nothing to do with the likelihood of getting caught or any potential penalties after being caught.
Some people do do business in that way, sure, but that doesn't change the ethics of those actions.
Agreed - this is inexcusable.
If you lose an investment because a later-stage investor is keen on you cheating existing investors out of what you already promised them, I'd say you dodged a bullet - you don't want them owning any piece of your company.
If your later-stage investors are so keen on working with investors who are willing to renege on their promises and legal obligations to earlier investors, that says something about:
(A) The types of entrepreneurs they want to work with
(B) How they themselves can expect to be treated in later rounds, when they are now the "earlier investors".
Angel investors who are concerned about their pro rata rights can't pretend that they exist in an ideal world. They can do one of two things: passively accept whatever they get, or take action in an effort to get what they want.
If you recognize the motivations of founders (and the pressures they may be put under), it is clear that the behavior of the angels themselves can either incentivize or disincentivize founders when it comes to honoring the obligations they made under different circumstances.
You're absolutely right. It is. But as an investor, you are bound to get hurt if you assume that everybody you're conducting business with will do so. Again, you can either deal with the world as it exists, or lament the fact that it isn't perfect.
In boxing, fighters are instructed to protect themselves at all times. That approach is a decent one outside of the boxing ring too.
I can choose to conduct myself in an ethical manner. I can't assume you will do the same. Get it?
If you go through life under the mistaken assumption that nobody is willing to hit below the belt, and you never take action to prevent and defend against such blows, you will eventually be hurt. There's nothing wrong with accepting the fact that some folks will play dirty, and please don't fall into the trap of believing that taking action to protect your interests requires you to play dirty too. It doesn't.
Once again, if you acknowledge the motivations of other individuals and the pressures they might come under, you are less likely to be caught off guard by actions they might take in response to them. If you adjust your behavior accordingly, you can often incentivize them to do the right thing when they otherwise wouldn't had you acted passively and/or obliviously.
Example: if you invested $25K in a $250,000 seed round and haven't talked to the founder in six months, don't be surprised if he doesn't fight tooth and nail for your pro rata rights.
-- Ah, I understand. Your comment is addressed to the seed investors, not to the founders. As such, it's a fair point. The question of how the investors should behave is not what we're discussing, though.
What a terrible place to be put in as a company: A big opportunity you're incredibly excited about, but contingent on you screwing over the people who have helped get you to where you are in a small way.
I would encourage any founders who are put in this type of scenario to fight back hard. Investors that are worth their while will respect your loyalty and your refusal to go back on your word. If I were a later-stage investor who proposed something like that and the company came back strong saying, "That's not even on the table, because we're not going to do something below the belt" I would gain additional respect for that company.