Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading
by kasey_junk on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:04AM
(#8272272)
So the biggest argument against random matching (whether in batch auction or open market book orders) is that the easiest way to game it is to figure out your expected fill rate. Then you just raise your order volume such that your expected fill rate matches your risk profile.
For the advantage of removing the speed advantage, you get the downside of providing advantage to people that have the loosest risk profiles and you further complicate the audit burden such that it is impossible to follow.
Think of it from the perspective of a value investor that set a market order 6 months ago. Under the current system once their price becomes top of the book they have a virtual certainty of getting filled. Under a (fair) random match they have the exact same chance of getting filled as someone who literaly just put in their order.
For the advantage of removing the speed advantage, you get the downside of providing advantage to people that have the loosest risk profiles and you further complicate the audit burden such that it is impossible to follow.
Think of it from the perspective of a value investor that set a market order 6 months ago. Under the current system once their price becomes top of the book they have a virtual certainty of getting filled. Under a (fair) random match they have the exact same chance of getting filled as someone who literaly just put in their order.