News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Samsung's VR Headset Convinced John Carmack to Join O... by ekianjo on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:23PM (#8272162)
His largest achievements were years ago, though. Doom was one, Quake another, and Quake 3 probably the last big step. Afterwards, he hasn't distinguished himself so much (I don't think Rage was very impressive, for example), so unless you keep pushing the limits every single time, your reputation can fade quickly.
Re:How Samsung's VR Headset Convinced John Carmack to Join O... by teamonkey on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:05AM (#8272273)
The Doom 3 engine was impressive at the time for its dynamic lighting and shadows.

He also developed megatextures for Rage. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MegaTexture

Re:How Samsung's VR Headset Convinced John Carmack to Join O... by ekianjo on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:10AM (#8272282)
I don't know if you could the Doom 3 tech impressive - I always found that at the time, it looked like a dirty hack rather than being genuinely impressive. Later games with soft shadows looked much better. And for Rage I'm aware of the megatextures, but that looked horrible for anything that was close to you - again a failed tech.

EDIT: interesting, getting downvoted because I wasn't impressed by Carmack's later productions?

Re:How Samsung's VR Headset Convinced John Carmack to Join O... by Negitivefrags on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:25AM (#8272311)
Megatexture was simply a technology before it's time.

The problem is that there just isn't a way to ship the data set right now that you need to support it properly. The hardware is there, the infrastructure is not.

They really needed to ship several hundred gigs of textures to do it justice. Right now you can't realistically deliver that to players.

Now certainly basing a game off a technology that isn't ready for prime time is a mistake, but the technology itself is very impressive and the underlying concept will come back when the internet is fast enough that you can realistically expect someone to download a half terabyte game.

Re:How Samsung's VR Headset Convinced John Carmack to Join O... by ekianjo on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:47AM (#8272352)
> Now certainly basing a game off a technology that isn't ready for prime time is a mistake, but the technology itself is very impressive and the underlying concept will come back when the internet is fast enough that you can realistically expect someone to download a half terabyte game.

Well I agree with your statement, but I'm not sure the tech is worth it in the end. The current tech is advancing faster than the Megatexture one, and by the time the Megatexture becomes a reality again, we won't need it anymore. Look at all games coming out in 1 to 2 years, they look fantastic while still relying on traditional texture concepts.

On a side note, it did not help to sell the technology that Rage was a notoriously bad game (just like Doom3, but hey, it's not a popular opinion apparently not to like having monsters jumping at you right when you open a door).

Re:How Samsung's VR Headset Convinced John Carmack to Join O... by teamonkey on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:14PM (#8274695)
What do you mean by the current tech? I bet every streaming world engine programmer has look at megatextures and some of its concepts are in open world games available right now. Similarly the fast hard-edged shadows from Doom 3 were ahead of the curve.

And although I agree that as games Doom 3 and Rage were just OK, Carmack is known for his tech; I don't think he gets involved on the game design side.