"The way we move our bodies further changes the nature of our thoughts, and vice versa"
"Because we don’t have to devote much conscious effort to the act of walking, our attention is free to wander"
"Where we walk matters as well."
The validity of those claims might be up for debate too, but the article in no way claims that it is "simply" increased heart rate. The answer only "begins with changes to our chemistry".
But my point was more, "I was hoping for some science," really.
It could boil down to an instinctive awareness that I'm not in a place I know is absolutely safe, so I have to be ready to accept and react to external stimuli at any moment, even if I'm not currently feeling threatened; and creative thought, in this case, hijacks the "external" tag.
But yeah, science would be nice too.
Basically movement, especially aerobic (walk, run, etc.) but also complex movement (sports, music playing , martial arts) as explained in the book
1 causes neurogenesis (release of brain stem cells ) 2 increases the size of your hippocampus and and improves memory 3 creates new brain circuits for the movement but these circuits are able to be recruited by different tasks 4 increases the production and balance of neurotransmitters and other hormones 5 increases and regulates executive function And a lot more complex processes in the brain. This occurs immediately but increases with more exercise . It's interesting stuff and ratey explains well.
I originally suspected walking has more to do with psychology, specifically paradoxic intention, than it does with physiology. That being easily distracted allows your mind to drift, whereas aiming to solve a problem keeps your mind stuck in the same unfruitful paths of thought. It's great that there is some science behind it.
Basically, if you are well adapted to running and it does not take a lot of mental effort to run, you aren't really draining your "bucket" of mental energy for the day very much, so you get the positive effects. However, if you go into a place where the training takes a high degree of concentration (say, running easy, but a lot), or by running very hard, this is a heavy cognitive load task that requires much concentration due to the pain, etc.
So, basically, its the same as walking for a lot of people. As long as you are in a reasonably comfortable zone where you can think, it works well.
I thought the journal articles linked to do a good job of substantiating the author's claims.
I would have guessed that walking helps us think because it gets us to a position where our problem isn't directly in front of us, nor are our distractions. But I was really hoping to instead get some science about that sort of thing. I mean, I guess it's cool to know that there are some mental tests which some people are slightly worse at when walking, and the Nabokov quote at the beginning was quite interesting even though it has absolutely nothing to do with the article, but I'm just left... unsatisfied.