News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: MealDays – Meal planner for my wife by eevilspock on Thursday September 04, 2014 @10:50AM (#8268575)
It has a login and extensive help info, so is clearly targeting far more than his wife.

Why the downvotes? I wrote "Gives the impression", which is valuable feedback for someone trying to design an attractive product.

[EDIT] To answer icebraining: It's relevant to his marketing. It may also be indicative of his preconceptions of the market. If he's intentionally aiming at traditional women, then great. It will turn others off.

Re:Show HN: MealDays – Meal planner for my wife by obvious_throw on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:07AM (#8268664)
It's the presumption that traditional household structures are archaic. Plenty of modern households operate on the basis of traditional role separation, and it has nothing to do with oppression.
Re:Show HN: MealDays – Meal planner for my wife by icebraining on Thursday September 04, 2014 @10:57AM (#8268608)
How is that relevant feedback for the site if it doesn't appear in it at all?
Re:Show HN: MealDays – Meal planner for my wife by jasonlotito on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:58AM (#8268979)
> It has a login and extensive help info, so is clearly targeting far more than his wife.

I tried to find the part where OP was turning this into a business and trying to market it to customers. I assumed this was like most other "Show HNs" and was simple something someone created for his wife and decided others might find it interesting or useful.

> Why the downvotes? I wrote "Gives the impression", which is valuable feedback for someone trying to design an attractive product.

Because your post gave the impression that you were misrepresenting what was fairly clear to many others. You are also giving the impression that you know far more than you actually do. You are finally giving the impression that Show HN is not the place for this. Frankly, all your comments give the impression of someone who isn't honestly contributing to this discussion.

That's probably why you are getting down votes. That, and your lack of HN etiquette.