News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by bluecalm on Thursday September 04, 2014 @09:27AM (#8268061)
>>Naively, couldn't all the craziness about HFT be resolved by enforcing a 1-second tick on the markets?

There are several arguments against it:

1)liquidity is good(1), more liquidity is better; why artificially limit liquidity, just let people provide as much as needed at as low price as market dictates;

2)Options are good(2), limiting liquidity increases prize of certain options (as issuer needs liquidity to offer options and the less liquidity there is the more expensive issuing those becomes, the effect might be small between 1s and 0s but it's still there)

3)Certain types of arbitrage would be less efficient. Arbitrage is good(3).

(1)-the concept of liquidity is that when you have some goods you want to sell, you don't need to invest time/effort/money to sell it; that in turns frees your time to do productive stuff; the effect is obvious in situations like retail stores buying from manufacturer (so manufacturer don't need to do advertising, building stores etc. themselves so they have more resources to actually produce goods); the effect doesn't disappear magically at 1 second scale, more liquidity (faster, cheaper) is always better for overall productivity.

(2)-options allow certain ventures which normally would be too high variance (forgive the gambling term) to pursue; they are form of insurance; reducing risk is almost always good but it costs to provide; the lower the prize, the better;

(3)-arbitrage is good because the prices of goods/stocks become close to true value; we want that, we also want to pay for that as little as possible; the more effective the arbitrage the better, why stop at 1 second, when you can have cheaper/better ?

This is not the whole story but those points are clear benefits of HFT. Liquidity is cheaper today than it ever was. Spreads are the lowest as well. Some people who used to make bank charging ridiculous spreads are now not making bank - this again is great.

The arms race argument is that resources go into something counter-productive (like stockpiling nukes) instead into something productive. In case of HFT resources (at least some of the time) go into something desirable. It is a race but it is a race to improve desirable things (liquidity, arbitrage). You rarely hear argument about "arm race" in situations like that. It's usually called progress. Usually we applaud progress in situations where service provides needs to compete to offer the best/cheapest product. In case of HFT this point is often somehow overlooked.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by conistonwater on Thursday September 04, 2014 @10:28AM (#8268416)
I think none of these arguments are very good against the idea of one-auction-a-second.

1) Liquidity is good, but remember who it is for. Uninformed traders, who want possession of the asset itself, will not care about a one-second delay because one second is too small an amount of time in human terms. Being able to trade a fraction of a second earlier is of no benefit. Being able to trade quickly on human timescales is the great benefit of algorithmic trading.

Informed traders, such as market makers, even market-making algorithms, also shouldn't care about a one-second delay. Their contribution to the market is the price. If you are a very good market maker, and you can quote prices better than anyone else in the market, your prices will be the better ones anyway, regardless of how the market is structured. And the profits are the market's rewards for quoting good prices, not trading quickly.

I would say the general idea is that liquidity providers and liquidity consumers compete, above all, on the price, and a one-second delay does nothing to hurt their incentives.

2) Again, I think it's quite obvious that on human timescales, on which actual economic decisions are made, there is no benefit to information arriving just a fraction earlier than it would otherwise. If you think of a market's purpose as revealing the price of an asset, it really shouldn't matter if the price is revealed 1ms earlier. What matters is that it is revealed at all, and revealed correctly with as many market participants as possible.

3) Because arbitrage becomes better when it contributes information to the market, not when it contributes information to the market 1ms earlier than another arbitrageur.

I think your points are completely valid arguments for algorithmic trading. Algorithms providing market participants with better prices than humans are indeed better for everyone. But for high-frequency trading, with the emphasis on high-frequency, I don't think this is very convincing.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by bluecalm on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:04AM (#8268647)
>>. Being able to trade a fraction of a second earlier is of no benefit. Being able to trade quickly on human timescales is the great benefit of algorithmic trading. Informed traders, such as market makers, even market-making algorithms, also shouldn't care about a one-second delay.

I think the other poster countered it well:

>>The impact is that by being fast market makers can reduce some of their risk, which means that they can price more aggressively. If they can't reduce that risk via speed, they will reduce it in other ways, namely pricing less aggressively. This will increase price spreads and decrease liquidity.

Human investors may not care about getting stuff 1ms faster but they should care about getting the stuff cheaper (or selling it for better price).

>>Again, I think it's quite obvious that on human timescales, on which actual economic decisions are made, there is no benefit to information arriving just a fraction earlier than it would otherwise.

Well, yeah, but again more stuff happens in one second than in one milisecond. It means there is more risk of more bad things happening. If there is possibility of more bad things happening the liquidity providers need to price liquidity higher to mitigate that new risk.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by conistonwater on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:12AM (#8268703)
Fair enough, I think I just disagree with you on how much new information is created in a second that needs to be priced into the market.
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by bluecalm on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:18AM (#8268749)
Well, it might not be much. Maybe even at some point it really is a race to the bottom kind of situation but why make judgement about it ?

If ISPs compete offering bigger and bigger bandwidth and faster and faster ping then it becomes pointless at some point again as only thing new competitor achieves is taking place of the incumbent without contributing significantly to what customers get. 100GB/sec or 1TB/sec, who cares. 1 second tick is similar to 100GB cap - supposedly there is no point at making the technology more efficient any more. Your argument comes down to: "The cost of providing new technology is higher than gains customer get and that is achieved by putting previous provider of the services out of business - hence waste".

It might be true or it might not. We just usually don't care much because that is one of the situations where free market/competition does well in practice. Those technological arm races have other benefits as well, you never know what other uses the technology is going to have or what kinds of scientific advancement it stimulates. One day you may have 35% faster ping from Tokyo to New York because instead of optic fibers the connection will use some of technology mentioned in the article.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by harryh on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:15AM (#8268716)
But do you agree that automating market making has lead to lower spreads and thus lowered the cost of trading?
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by conistonwater on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:19AM (#8268751)
Yes, I agree. Was that not clear? If not, I expressed myself poorly.
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by harryh on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:26AM (#8268791)
Ah cool. It's much more important to focus on these reduced costs than to focus on the timescales involved in HFT. You are right to say that humans don't care about millisecond timescales but they do very much care about price.

Only the computers care about those timescales but it's by fighting it out there that they can give you the best price.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by dalore on Thursday September 04, 2014 @10:18AM (#8268363)
How does 1 second ticks stop liquidity and arbitrage? It just stops the faster connections wins.

HFT aren't really adding liquidity since they only buy when they can sell straight away. So there was already a liquid purchase there.

Arbitrage, if something is cheaper elsewhere, the 1 second tick will still bring the price into parity.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @10:42AM (#8268515)
"How does 1 second ticks stop liquidity and arbitrage? It just stops the faster connections wins."

No it doesn't. Let's suppose in your 1 second time tick you have more people attempting to buy at a price than sell at the same price? Who gets to buy and who doesn't? If it is FIFO then the speed advantage is still there. If it isn't FIFO it can be applied to non 1 second ticks as well.

"HFT aren't really adding liquidity since they only buy when they can sell straight away."

This is a completely untrue statement. Lots and lots of HFT hold inventory. Their inventory periods can range from seconds to minutes to weeks.

The impact is that by being fast market makers can reduce some of their risk, which means that they can price more aggressively. If they can't reduce that risk via speed, they will reduce it in other ways, namely pricing less aggressively. This will increase price spreads and decrease liquidity.