News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Standard Markdown by jrochkind1 on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @07:39PM (#8266024)
So, Gruber is fine with people implementing their own markdown processors without his permission, and still call it markdown, and he even likes it when they do that, he likes the flexibility and multiple flavors of markdown.

But if people implementing their own markdown processors try to write a spec or grammar for what they are implementing... he is not fine with it, and considers legal action? It's okay to write a markdown parser, as long as you don't write a spec for it?

There may be a way to justify that position rationally, but I doubt there is legally. He's already abandoned any claims to trademark, by making it clear he's okay with people making their own markdown parsers and describing them as 'markdown parsers', without his permission.

Re:Standard Markdown by MBCook on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @08:57PM (#8266246)
My position (and what I see others taking) is not a problem with formalizing Markdown, which many see as a good thing, but the name.

If they made this an called it StackMark it would be fine.

But this feels more like a power play. Like when Microsoft came and made Visual J++ in an attempt to take control of Java from Sun. It seems oddly and unnecessarily mean spirited and hostile. The name seems designed to either engender confusion or as a slight against the original.

Re:Standard Markdown by jrochkind1 on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @10:05PM (#8266436)
How about "Specification-flavored Markdown"?
Re:Standard Markdown by MBCook on Thursday September 04, 2014 @12:38AM (#8266790)
I'd accept that. Seems unwieldily (so it wouldn't be my choice), but I don't think it's outright hostile to the original.

We've got Disqus, Stack Overflow, GitHub, and others. John has referred in the past that he doesn't mind how GitHub has GitHub flavored mark down. This new one could be called Atwood flavored (to pick a name I know is involved). Or they could have stuck with GitHub Flavored markdown and just expand the GitHub flavor.