Re:How a new HTML element will make the Web faster
by ollysb on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @02:16PM
(#8259191)
Their proposed solution offers more flexibility in that you can use media queries to specify the upper/lower bounds and also specify the filenames. This feels over-engineered though, firstly because the above solution provides enough information to switch between images (we're not changing the layout here) and secondly because a filename convention is adequate for referencing them. The third reason that I dislike their solution is that it introduces presentation logic(media queries) into html.
Is your thought here that not one of the dozens of people involved considered this sort of syntax during those months or years or work? (That seems unlikely.) Or do you think their reasons for rejecting it were unsound? (You don't seem to have said why.) I'm just not understanding what you're aiming for here.