News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to my' pop-up bullshit

You all know what I am talking about. The page loads and boom... right smack in the middle your webpage a pop-up/over is displayed offering shitty freebies or periodic spam. Even worse is when the pop-up/over timer is set to show after a certain number of page views. You are not clever, you are most likely killing page views, time on site and jacking up your bounce rates. For what? Fake email addressees?

I understand having people give you their email address is a great feeling but the whole pop-up/over thing is a poor user experience. Have you not learned anything from the past? Browser pop-ups sucked and pop-up/over plugins are even more annoying. If you need to have one, move it and don't obstruct my view. Any developer who feels the need to show a pop-up/over is almost as bad as the publishers who require users to 'like' to view a video.

There are two ways to do something. The first one is with taste. The second one is a pop-up/over.

You decide.

( 9 comments | 16 points | on HN )
Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by notduncansmith on Thursday September 11, 2014 @01:35AM (#8301049)
We[1] always encourage our clients to go for the tasteful option. Trying to force opt-ins for anything other than mass-market consumer crap has led to universally negative results for our clients.

[1] http://fullcourseemails.com

Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by nathancahill on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @12:28PM (#8258549)
It's been widely blogged about as the most effective way to capture email addresses. It'll probably be around for a while.

(flashing "YOU WON" banner ads were also effective, back in the day)

Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by unsquare on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @02:18PM (#8259200)
Not only are they effective, but they do not increase the bounce rate (in most cases), unlike popular belief.
Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by andrewhillman on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @12:51PM (#8258688)
it's an awful user experience regardless.
Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by _RPM on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @11:36PM (#8266642)
I find it annoying. I had an aggressive solicitation occur on twitter recently. The person had exploited a new feature of twitter advertisements where you can "click to subscribe". I wasn't aware that they would give my email out via a click, but apparently so. The person would not stop trying to follow up with it. I ended up muting the entity (or person)
Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by thwarted on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:48PM (#8259036)
It's even worse on mobile, where the popup/overlay is difficult to close because it's larger than the viewport. If it takes me longer than 3 seconds to figure out how to close the popup, I end up just closing the tab.
Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by andrewhillman on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:54PM (#8259070)
Don't even get me started with mobile ;) Complete nightmare.
Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by garysvpa1 on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @12:33AM (#8261519)
I find them annoying too. They can just put their freebie message somewhere on the page, not to obstruct view. If the reader wants the content, he will subscribe.
Re:Hey devs/publishers, cut the shit with your 'subscribe to... by jordsmi on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:03PM (#8258766)
Welcome to the world of internet marketing/advertising where annoying/obtrusive/ugly wins out over being user friendly.