Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by Drakim on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:12AM
(#8256746)
Really? A company can just make a TV ad where they say "We are the most environmentally friendly company in this country" when they aren't?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
by dalke on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @01:57PM
(#8259084)
Can TCBY say they are "The Country's Best Yogurt"? Can an cider mill ask "
How do we Make the Best Apple Cider in West Michigan?"
(Quoting from http://www.klackleorchards.com/make-best-apple-cider-west-mi... ). Team Razer says they "make the best gaming peripherals in the world" (http://www.razerzone.com/team/join ) and Surefoot makes "the best fitting, best performing ski boots in the world" (http://www.surefoot.com/news.php ).
The answer is "yes." Under US law, these are "harmless puffery."
A search, btw, finds that SUNOCO is "the most environmentally-friendly company in the entire [petroleum] industry" http://prezi.com/2m6blwsr9u9c/geo-greenwash-ad/ and Sediment Removal Solutions is "the most environmentally friendly company around" http://www.sedimentremovalsolutions.com/franchise.html .
At some point there may be problems, but as there's no standard for 'environmentally friendly', the claim is rather vague in the first place. Still, see Kasky v. Nike (http://reclaimdemocracy.org/nike/ ) for the question of if a company's press statements, in this case about Nike's non-use of sweat shop labor, counts a protected free speech.