Re:Hyperreal numbers: infinities and infinitesimals
by pfortuny on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @05:00AM
(#8256457)
Actually, Newton and Leibniz were all about this: infinitesimals. It was only in the XIX Century with D'Alembert and especially when Weisrstrass was ill-digested that we got the epsilon-delta down our throats.
Evanescent quantities are quite natural to me.
Re:Hyperreal numbers: infinities and infinitesimals
by mcguire on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @11:28AM
(#8258103)
As I recall, there was a fluff-up between Bishop Berkeley[1] and the Newton camp regarding the issue[2], in the 18th century.
"Mathematical historian Judith Grabiner comments, 'Berkeley’s criticisms of the rigor of the calculus were witty, unkind, and — with respect to the mathematical practices he was criticizing — essentially correct'."
Re:Hyperreal numbers: infinities and infinitesimals
by darkxanthos on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @09:24AM
(#8257346)
Oh totally. I know they were. From the wikipedia article though it seems like they were much less rigorous about their treatment and that it wasn't until the mid-20th century that there was a formal treatment of them.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreal_number
I still think there's a certain elegance of not needing to define a whole new set of numbers, but there's also an elegance to the intuition of infinitesimals and infinitesimals.