Re:A girl with three biological parents
by maxerickson on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:40AM
(#8252545)
It says The HFEA's scientific reviews dismissed Morrow's findings as not relevant to humans because they were done on inbred animals.
I think that the animals were inbred was probably important to that decision.
There's also a paragraph where another scientist says:
"Whereas the original techniques were used with only [experiments from] mice, rabbits, lab animals... the big difference here is we also have issue of human embryos and this work has been tested in macaque monkeys in primates. All those were very useful, reassuring… hence why we came to the conclusion that this is not unsafe."
So "there have been problems with all species" is not a fair representation of the information given in the article.
Re:A girl with three biological parents
by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 01, 2014 @03:23PM
(#8254315)
Agreed with your last sentence, I clearly skimmed over too fast - but that doesn't alter the conclusion for me; surely you'd want to actually look at the human subjects (at least) that resulted from this procedure in depth before concluding that it's not unsafe?
Re:A girl with three biological parents
by maxerickson on Monday September 01, 2014 @04:56PM
(#8254656)
I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt. As it is, "not unsafe" is a pretty soft statement to make, it isn't a declaration that there will be zero problems, it just reveals a certain amount of confidence that the procedure will be successful in humans. Perhaps they could have found a better way of phrasing it, but I don't see it as intentionally misleading.
Isn't this an important enough issue to do a study?
Why would you say "there have been problems with all species undergoing this procedure who have been studied" and "humans having this procedure haven't been studied [in depth]" and conclude that the procedure was "not unsafe"?
Who gains from pushing this through??