Re:Social Login Myths Debunked
by scrollaway on Sunday August 31, 2014 @05:41PM
(#8250463)
> Persona assumes something trivially false for most end users
No. No no no no no. No.
This is not "trivially false". Maybe if you said "Persona assumes something which is false for some end users" then you would have a point.
What persona does is being practical. You are identified by an email address which is already the way most people are identified on the web (immediate integration with existing services and no introduction of a new concept such as an "URI identity" a la openid).
Your email address can still be updated as long as you own it and the web app allows it, as you would expect. But using a username instead of an email address would be worse. How many times have I changed my username? I love my current one but it is short and not always available: I sometimes have to use an alternative one. Not to mention the times people outright steal my username; something they cannot do with an email address for obvious reasons.
Please. Persona does have flaws, so don't waste time burning it on a non-issue.
No. No no no no no. No.
This is not "trivially false". Maybe if you said "Persona assumes something which is false for some end users" then you would have a point.
What persona does is being practical. You are identified by an email address which is already the way most people are identified on the web (immediate integration with existing services and no introduction of a new concept such as an "URI identity" a la openid).
Your email address can still be updated as long as you own it and the web app allows it, as you would expect. But using a username instead of an email address would be worse. How many times have I changed my username? I love my current one but it is short and not always available: I sometimes have to use an alternative one. Not to mention the times people outright steal my username; something they cannot do with an email address for obvious reasons.
Please. Persona does have flaws, so don't waste time burning it on a non-issue.