With respect to psychedelics, they actually do affect your brain. You'd be hard-pressed to tease apart what portion of the outcome was unaffected by the drug when claiming that the results were all due to the Placebo Effect.
Re:Psychedelics in problem-solving experiment
by lutusp on Sunday August 31, 2014 @02:54AM
(#8248644)
That's true, but there's no chance to have a control group. No one having an acid trip can possibly compare his subjective experience to someone who's taken a sugar pill. And without control groups and other strict controls, human studies are next to useless.
The above means that the Placebo Effect cannot be realistically guarded against or dismissed.
> The above means that the Placebo Effect cannot be realistically guarded against or dismissed.
This is a little different than the parent's statement (which I was responding to):
> I tend to view them mostly as analogous to Dumbo's magic feather.
I have been temped in the past to equate this magnate character's conviction to PG's belief that it was Lisp which allowed Viaweb to do so well.
I do not disaprove of religion, functional programming, or psychedelics. But in the instances described, I tend to view them mostly as analogous to Dumbo's magic feather.