Unless you screwed up assembling the thing, the chances of something other than a drive failing are pretty small. I mean, not zero; don't count on hardware... I'm just saying, even if you have to get a $150/hr guy in to fix your bad hardware, that just doesn't happen very often. way less than once per server. Way less than once per every 10 servers (assuming you didn't screw up the assembly, and that you rotate out the server after 3 years.)
So yeah, there are many situations where it makes sense to rent, especially if you can't use 8 cores/ 32GiB ram of capacity. but if you use a whole server (32GiB ram/8 core; go virtual until you need that capacity, I say.) the cost advantages of owning hardware yourself are overwhelming. Sure, there are reasons to rent... I'm just saying, owning ends up costing you a /lot/ less money.
My solution is to run most stuff in a colo on dell boxes running the linux-vserver kernel patch, sort of a cheap mans cloud solution.
These things add up.
Imagine comparing a $10/mo hosting account with a colocated server for $100/mo.
There are a plethora of scenarios that don't warrant owning or running your own hardware.