Nothing is objectively art; art is always in the eye of the beholder, but it's only real art to someone if they would want it even if no one else ever saw it.
Take a toilet nailed to the wall. If the person who created this thing would have done so if he had known that no one else would ever see it, if he would have nailed the toilet to his own wall at home knowing that he was the only one who would ever see it just because HE HIMSELF wanted to look at it, then it really is art to him. It's not any art that I'm interested in, but that doesn't matter. All art is subjective. It is a genuine expression of his own esthetic desires. It IS art to him.
But if he would never consider such a thing for himself, if it's only part of a show he puts on for others in hopes of getting paid ("it speaks to the inhumanity of corporate greed...blah, blah" he explains greedily), then it's just a commercial product. If it's nothing he would have any interest in without the audience, but it's about getting attention, not money, then it's a publicity stunt, not art. To the artist, it's not art. (If it really is art to the artist, it can ALSO be a commercial product or publicity stunt while remaining art to him.)
And if the wealthy customer would have no interest in it if he couldn't show off his "statement" to others, then it's not art to him, either. It's some sort of signalling, or a commercial investment, or whatever, but it's not art to him. And if potential buyers knew that it was not even art to the artist, what might that mean to them?
Of course, I can't be sure what really is in someone else's mind, but if I doubt that the artist would sincerely want this poo-covered crucifix in his own living room for his private enjoyment, nor that the rich people swooning over its deep meaning would care if they couldn't show off their depth to their friends, it means I'm doubting that this piece of junk is really art to anybody.
You seem to be referring to Marcel Duchamp's Fountain (the urinal) and if so you are missing the point.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fountain_%28Duchamp%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Readymades_of_Marcel_Duchamp
> Take a toilet nailed to the wall. If the person who created this thing would have done so if he had known that no one else would ever see it, if he would have nailed the toilet to his own wall at home knowing that he was the only one who would ever see it just because HE HIMSELF wanted to look at it, then it really is art to him. It's not any art that I'm interested in, but that doesn't matter. All art is subjective. It is a genuine expression of his own esthetic desires. It IS art to him.
Art is a statement and you can't isolate that statement in a vacuum that would cut it from its historical perspective.
> Nothing is objectively art; art is always in the eye of the beholder, but it's only real art to someone if they would want it even if no one else ever saw it.
Of course, but the context around the piece of art is indeed objective.
Would it be accurate to complete the idea and say that it is about marketing & networking instead? The personality of the artist is just as much for sale as the "art".
I think these artists are making a serious and successful artistic statement, albeit a highly indirect one. At the same time I find it sort of deplorable because I think art should be an intimate personal experience rather than a spectacular sociological one. Somehow I derive much more enjoyment from my own failed or inchoate than I do from most of what is promoted to me as art, with artists' statements that read like so much ad copy.
I have an illustrator friend who would sure love to know how to get paid.
Highbrow modern art has a very very very tiny niche market of people who mainly invest in art of large sums of money for complex and personal reasons that normally boil down to looking for the next Pollock, Warhol, etc. There's an entire ecosystem of galleries, showings, parties, and auction houses devoted to these highly wealthy patrons. It's a pretty insular and self-involved world.
An artists biggest skill in this market has little to do with their technical skill. Technical skill is easy and can be purchased on Fiverr if you need.
Art schools are part of this market.
Most people on the other hand don't go to galleries. They buy prints, hallmark cards, download wallpapers from DeviantArt, etc. Illustrators and graphic designers are thriving in this market, but are totally ignored by the high brow market (unless you get big enough).
Basically, it's just artists following market demands.