Virtually all people in the US recognize that it's not. Some people think that's a positive; others think it's a negative. Many of the most significant issues in US politics are about whether we should enact new regulations, retract old ones, or revise them in place.
http://www.cheltenham.gov.uk/info/200008/benefits/565/local_...
A landlord can charge what they like, but if they want people on benefit to be able to afford the property they should price it near the LHA rates.
There are some restrictions on sudden increases once you've got a tennant, but the landlord could just evict the tennant.
England has the balance mostly right (I'd prefer some slighty stronger protections for good tennants and fiercer penalties for terrible tennants).
(doesn't New York still have rent control?)