Now, this gets to the real issue: We need a source for these magic numbers, it needs to be trusted and available and verifiable by everyone, and it needs to be unpredictable and unknowable until a specific time.
What possible sources are there? You could imagine a centralized system, where some computer on the internet spits out a random number for the next 'magic key' every minute. But of course, you have to trust the owner of this computer and so we'd lose all the decentralized features of Bitcoin.
Another possibility: Tie the magic key to some public knowledge, e.g. the value of the NASDAQ at a specific time. Again, this still has problems as 1) there's a limited range of possible values, so miners could pre-compute various versions, and 2) the value could be gamed by market traders.
Anyway, I don't have an answer for the ideal source of these 'magic keys', but if someone could come up with one, you could keep all of bitcoin's mechanisms while vastly reducing its energy waste
This would seem to lead to a situation where, after a proof-of-work block is minted, those minting POW blocks relax and those minting POS blocks march things forward for each of their accounts until they find the earliest time that satisfies any of them - at which point they simply wait until that time arrives (for themselves or anyone else playing).
I have a suggestion for how to deal with these magic numbers. Make 9 out of 10 blocks duds (and it should be known in advance which), that contain very little reward. This means that, most mining power will switch of for these blocks, and only be active for the other 1 of 10 blocks.
While proofs of work are wasteful, the only alternative I know of is simply entrusting some third party with control of the network.