News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High-achieving men and women are described differently in... by anigbrowl on Thursday August 28, 2014 @07:22PM (#8240281)
As complete populations, girls aren't any smarter than boys on average, but in those programs the girls are always among the top students -- because it's only the most exceptional girls who overcome the social factors which keep most of their peers out of those subjects.

Social factors like the assumption that women who consistently outrank their peers are 'significantly more aggressive'? I'm sure you mean well but your post here seems like a classic example of circular reasoning. You assume that because the total population of women entering such programs is not any smarter on average, those who consistently perform well rather than quitting must therefore be of only average intelligence, and are making up for it by being more aggressive and competitive (than, I assume, the average man). It's equally possible that women of average or median intelligence deicde they're unlikely to succeed in that field and drop out, leaving only the best female students.

My wife is an EE and there were only 2 women in her graduating class out of a total of 30 or 35. She's had to put up her share of colleagues complaining about her being 'abrasive' and so on. It seems to me that this only exists relative to the complainant's prior expectations of women, eg her emails tend to be short and to the point rather than chatty or friendly. The horror.

Re:High-achieving men and women are described differently in... by cperciva on Thursday August 28, 2014 @07:34PM (#8240326)
the total population of women entering such programs is not any smarter on average

Sorry, I was unclear. I meant that the total worldwide population of women is no smarter on average than the worldwide population of men. The evidence points to the subset of women who enter CS and engineering being smarter on average than the subset of men who enter CS and engineering.

It's equally possible that women of average or median intelligence deicde they're unlikely to succeed in that field and drop out, leaving only the best female students.

From everything I've seen it's less a matter of dropping out and more a matter of not entering those programs in the first place; but yes, there are societal influences which result in "marginal" men entering those fields while "marginal" women do not.

Re:High-achieving men and women are described differently in... by anigbrowl on Thursday August 28, 2014 @07:46PM (#8240383)
The evidence points to the subset of women who enter CS and engineering being smarter on average than the subset of men who enter CS and engineering.

Isn't this rather at odds with your hypothesis that they do well because of being more aggressive? I mean, perhaps that is true but if the data suggests that women entering those programs are in fact smarter why would your hypothesis be any more likely than the existence of bias in HR departments?

Re:High-achieving men and women are described differently in... by true_religion on Thursday August 28, 2014 @08:13PM (#8240519)
> sn't this rather at odds with your hypothesis that they do well because of being more aggressive?

I don't think that's what he said originally. He said that aggressive women are those who overcome the social pressure to not join a male dominated field like CS/tech.

To give an extreme example, you can be a timid man and still join CS simply because there's no pressure against you doing so, but if you were a timid woman you wouldn't be able to overcome the poor atmosphere women in STS face.

Re:High-achieving men and women are described differently in... by cperciva on Thursday August 28, 2014 @08:43PM (#8240620)
Yes, that's what I was trying to say.
Re:High-achieving men and women are described differently in... by tachyonbeam on Friday August 29, 2014 @12:06AM (#8241065)
Well, as a woman doing a computer science PhD, I'll say I initially felt that my advisor didn't respect my opinions, always argued against my ideas, even though I was better informed much of the time (and that's normal, he only has a mile-high view of my thesis work). This made me angry, and I didn't hesitate to show it. I stood up for myself and I must have come off as abrasive at times. Other factors may have contributed (I'm now the most senior student in the lab), but I feel like he treats me with more respect now, and our relationship has much improved.
Re:High-achieving men and women are described differently in... by cperciva on Friday August 29, 2014 @03:03AM (#8241429)
Not to discount your experiences (obviously I have no idea about the details), but I know some faculty who are dismissive of all their students' ideas -- and deliberately so, based on the argument that until a student is able to stand up for their ideas, they're not ready to receive a PhD.

Personally I think it's an unnecessarily cruel approach, but it does seem to produce good results at times.