A super specialised policy/visa designed to milk some of the meatiest benefits from immigration is an ugly hack.
We are eagerly following the all encompassing reforms, while what we actually need is for Congress to make legislation continuously. Who would have thought that this was their job? Instead we make a big deal about big legislations and watch senators flip charts and push rhetoric while working deals behind closed doors.
When advocating for manageable legislation with a whole lot of support and little floor time I've personally heard: "We cannot do it now, because we do not have the White House." "We cannot do it now because we don't have the majority in the Senate." "We cannot do it now because we dont have the 60 vote super majority." "We cannot do it now because its just not the right political atmosphere." This Fall, if health care fails, they'll have a perfect excuse not to touch immigration with a 10 foot pole. "We cannot do it now, because obviously it wouldn't pass, look at health care."
My personal favorite "It takes so much political capital to pass any immigration bill that legislators need to do it all at once and then not touch it for another 20 years." Ironically, that one comes from reform advocates. My personal favorite response to that was by Robert Kerrey (a former Senator, President of New School in New York) - "I got news for you, Congress comes back every year."
In geek terms. Why not iterate and see what works? What we have, obviously doesn't. Any legislation that we come up with today is almost guaranteed not to work in 5 to 10 years.
I was simply making a more general point about restrictions on immigration. If you take in to account all effects including the immigrant, the destination and the country of origin, you get a terrible economic net loss. It is similar to restricting trade in goods and services.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DREAM_Act
We need your support in pressuring legislators to action.
I lived in NYC myself. Besides not having to drive, is it really a better place to be for undocumented immigrants?
That, working my ass off, working my ass off some more, and a whole lot of help from people who care about me, to whom I am in debt for the rest of my life. I know too many who are not as lucky as me and it tears me apart to see their dreams shattered for no sensible reason and no wrongdoing of their own.
NYC is a better place for undocumented immigrants because you can rely on the police to help you, they are legally prevented from inquiring about your immigration status. On the other hand, we have stories of valedictorians being thrown into jail and put into deportation proceedings for rolling a stop sign in places like Texas (some people were able to get driver licenses a while back, in some states, no longer possible).
First, I think illegal immigration is still ILLEGAL immigration and yes, the laws need to be reformed but until they are, let's not be too devious in how we aid and abet criminal behaviors.
Second and more to the point, anybody who's considering immigrating to the US of A (or Canada) for "technology" will face a rude awakening in another 5-10 years. You're immigrating to the wrong hemisphere. Now if you think you might be a good producer of trash reality TV then hey! Come on over. That's where America truly excels.
I think that your stance is absolutely indefensible since the poster explicitly states that he came to America as a young child and 'inherited' his status as an illegal from his parents.
So, even if he/she has done everything possible to stay clear of the law (if there is one thing you do not do as an illegal it is breaking ANY laws, since that can lead to instant deportation) simply by walking around on the street there is a risk.
If you have been in a country for as long as you remember and you have been a productive element in that society then by any definition you are part of that society, and not a criminal.
To pretend it is otherwise because of a bunch of stupid pieces of paper is putting the horse behind the cart.
So, even if he/she has done everything possible to stay clear of the law ... been a productive element in that society
If he has been a productive member of society then he has broken several laws around the employment of illegals, including tax evasion.
It as if he broke in to your house and has been living in your attic. He contributed to the upkeep of the house by fixing a holes in the roof so that his bed would stay dry. Now that he has lived in your attic for so long he demands ownership since he doesn't remember living anywhere else and doesn't have anywhere else to go. ...in that society then by any definition you are part of that society
No, you are member of society when you live by the rules of that society, and take your punishment when you violate their rules. Doing what you want and breaking whichever rules you want because they don't apply to you doesn't make you member of society. That is not to say the law is correct, but violating them because you don't like them makes you a criminal not a citizen. If he were practicing Civil Disobedience then there would be a political component to his action instead of entitlement whining.Real criminals are people who do harm to others, not people who simply break bureaucratic rules.
6 months difference between legal and illegal seems a bit arbitrary.
We seem to have a different opinion on that.
Personally I think that any system - and any person - that can treat 6 months olds as criminals is seriously broken, and to be held in contempt.
Believe what you like. Personally I am happy with the fact that murder is illegal for everyone not just people over the age of 35. Personally I am happy that theft is illegal to everyone not just people over the age of 40. Personally I like the fact that courts are allowed to deal with assaults committed by minors and even have special rules regarding their care. I believe you have to have rules that apply to everybody, you can't decide that this isn't a crime today but wake up tomorrow and you get death row for it.
For someone that was brought in to the US and is now at an age to have completed their secondary education home is the United States. No amount of paper waving and applying of the rules is going to change that.
Anyway, I'm wasting my time with this, I only wish that in your life you will never ever come up against a situation where you will be forced to realize just how cruel your stance is.
We're not debating murder here, that's just a straw man. We are not dealing with assault, committed by minors or otherwise.
The subject was immigration, specifically by minors too young to even realize what that means.
you will be forced to realize just how cruel your stance is.
What is cruel about expecting people to live by the rules they have agreed to live by?
Yes and he is a grown up now and has known for years that he is in the wrong. Instead of doing the right thing he complains about how we should all just love him for it. It would be a big relief for him if he went home no more fear of being discovered, no more I can't do that because I might be found out, the ability to get an id, bank account, health insurance, take the GRE. If he wanted to go to grad school he could be back in a semester on a student visa.(according to travel.state.gov a student visa takes at most 120 days and $300) The subject was immigration, specifically by
minors too young to even realize what that means.
No I was talking about the fact that the rules apply to everyone, and the fact that is not a bad thing like you seem to think it is.Would you simply leave for a foreign country you have no knowledge of, abandoning your life, severing your relationships, giving up all of the property that you earned through your own endeavors, just because the law is the law?
Any rule that would compel you to do so is simply, unequivocally _wrong_, and deserves to be violated.
They even came up with a name for it, "enforcement through attrition." Make our life so horrible that we opt for voluntary departure. How fucked up is that? How full of bigotry do you have to be to come up with something like that?
To people who truly want to help, stop debating, stop listening. Start pressuring your legislators to action!
Second, I didn't immigrate here for "technology" or anything else. I grew up here. I went to school with brilliant engineers who now do brilliant things. I think YC itself is a testament to the talent that exists in this country. So, good luck with that thinking.
"Until the laws change illegal is illegal. We need to enforce the law not change it, illegal is illegal. ILLEGAL"
Did you know that there is butter that isn't butter?
If only our valedectorians got as deep a look as butter did. A man can dream.
In general, going somewhere else is not possible at all for many. Before one can go somewhere else he has to go back to his country of citizenship. Often thats simply not possible. Yet another case are stateless individuals who have nowhere to go period.
Even if you ignore all the human rights issues and look at the problem from an economically pragmatic point of view, it doesn't make any sense to maintain the status quo. Why should educated and obviously needed Americans be forced out of their homes and shipped out? To "not encourage illegal immigration in the future." Thats the argument I hear. Am I supposed to be a casualty of a political statement? I don't feel anything but American, so the people who wage the "cultural war" for votes and ratings can go ___ themselves. I'm fighting for my rights.
Maintaining the ability to keep people out when they want in requires cruelty. The tighter you want to keep the control, the crueller. The more they want in, the crueller. If you want to really really close a border, you need to be willing to kill people.
Have you ever considered going in to some sort of open battle about this. You're educated. It seems like you have the ability to articulate your position well. You would be able to gain empathy from Americans who will see you as an American under threat of deportation. Are there any support/advice channels for illegal immigrants in the NY?
When you're illegal somewhere your best chance is to lay low until there is some legislation that favors you.
Here in NL there was a guy from Turkey, that had started his own business. Very very successful, in fact, so successful that a newspaper decided to use him as the poster child for illegal immigrants that should get a passport.
Not that long afterwards he was deported, simply for having become 'visible'.
I was brought to the United States by my parents at a very young age. In the process I have inherited the title of an "illegal immigrant" from my parents. The DREAM Act is a legislation 10 years in the making. We have thousands of enterpreneurs, scientists, engineers, nurses, doctors, talent in every field imaginable going to waste in the United States; living in the shadows. Myself included.
Last year I graduated from NYU with a dual degree in electrical and computer engineering. My graduate school plans were shattered because I could not prove my identify for the purpose of taking the GREs. I cannot work, open a bank account, drive, get health insurance, go to a bar, take an interstate bus or train, fly, live or breathe. Yet, I am lucky, because I live in New York City. Those living almost anywhere else in the country cannot go to college or call the police at fear of deportation.
There are hundreds of thousands of us in the United States. I personally know hundreds of children, teens, and now young adults that have had their lives put on hold for Congress to "feel right" for immigration reform. I also know quite a few individuals who could not live like this anymore and have taken their skills elsewhere by going for voluntary departure (a path not open to all).
Next time your legislator tells you that this is not the right time for immigration reform, remind them of the experience of our butchered youth, remind them of the DREAM Act. I am a 23 year old American with no relief, rights, or equality in sight. Tragically, I am not alone.