Its somewhat OT, but thanks for Hamachi! It made many a late night gaming session possible in my teens and early twenties, and was always an astoundingly simple piece of software to use considering everything it did.
My pleasure, glad to have been of some help :)
Cool to get a ping from Hamachi's author. I deliberately did not use Hamachi while designing ZeroTier since I didn't want to pollute my headspace with something so similar. :)
ZeroTier right now is sort of an OSS Hamachi, since I figured this would be a good starting application, but I've got different longer-term goals in mind. (Won't be abandoning that application though.)
TCP hole punching works just fine in practice, but it's certainly a part of the "long tail" of empirical hacks that allow bumping NAT traversal rates into 95+% range. Detecting NATs that decrement ports is another. Ports that are incremented/decremented by more than 1 is yet another. And there's also UPnP that gives you another percent or so.
I was doing this as a part of the Hamachi project [0], almost 10 years ago, and this long tail was absolutely instrumental to being able to serve hundreds of thousands of clients off just few measly Dell servers for $300/mo in hosting costs.
[0] http://swapped.cc/hamachi