Re:Google introduces "Fast Flip"
by wmeredith on Monday September 14, 2009 @10:20PM
(#823105)
Yikes! If your UI is what's surprising people, then I would generally consider that a bad thing. By their definition, a surprising UI is bad. (Obviously there are exceptions but they're very very rare.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
It depends. There's surprising as in what is this software doing!? and there surprising as in the wow, this is so much better.
The pinch zoom is a perfect example of a surprising UI that most people love. When someone sees a two fingered pinch zoom for the first time they go wow, that's awesome. Surprising isn't always bad.
I wouldn't necessarily call "pinch zoom" surprising, though, b/c the first thing I thought after seeing it was, _this is so intuitive -- i.e. unsurprising -- you never have to show anyone twice_. The wow-factor is less surprise, and more delight.
Re:Google introduces "Fast Flip"
by thaumaturgy on Tuesday September 15, 2009 @12:52AM
(#823304)
Well, like I said, we've got other tricks yet, and it's still a fledgling system.
We just thought that we had a better UI for browsing content than anyone else had yet, and then Google debuted something that was uncomfortably close.
But, I'm hoping that the really surprising thing will be the ... naaaah. :-)