That was well worded! I tried to say that in the article but didn't manage it as succinctly :D
Personally I love how it makes it easy to convert existing shell scripts. One of my projects is Vaprobash - vagrant provisioning bash scripts - which contains mostly non-idempotent scripts. (It uses bash scripts purposefully as a teaching tool). Making an ansible version of it will be nice as well.
Re:An Ansible Tutorial
by marcoamorales on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @12:45PM
(#8228164)
I'm not sure what bootstrapping overhead you're talking about. You can do a knife bootstrap to bootstrap nodes, not sure about puppet.
Re:An Ansible Tutorial
by dangerlibrary on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @01:14PM
(#8228322)
I didn't say it was difficult, I said it was annoying. The bootstrapping step isn't just easier when using Ansible, it doesn't exist.
The idempotence issue of shell scripts addressed (with Go): https://github.com/visionmedia/stack/
Also, there's Rex now (in Perl), which, in my opinion, is better than Ansible as I hate writing code in YAML - I'd rather do it in Perl if Python/Go/Rust are not a option.
Re:An Ansible Tutorial
by dangerlibrary on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @03:30PM
(#8229016)
Stack looks cool, but I can't use it to repair a broken configuration. A commit log recording which commands have already run doesn't verify that the system is in the correct state.
Come one, it's not that hard to do a yum install puppet or use cobbler for provisioning and install puppet along with the OS.
What's scary about shell scripts is the lack of idempotence (if you accidentally run them twice, things break).
What's annoying about chef/puppet is the bootstrapping overhead -- you can't start from a blank slate system, because you still need to install puppet-client or ruby+dependencies. So now you're paying to store a bunch of semi-pre-configured images with some out-of-date ruby gems or an old puppet-client. If you want to start from a blank image, then you're using shell scripts to install the toolchain that will let you avoid using shell scripts (or worse - doing it by hand!).
Ansible is idempotent ssh + shell scripting, so it solves the 'blank slate' problem nicely. It only requires python, which is bundled by default on ubuntu servers.