Re:Ask HN: Startup stole our software, and raised $2MM with ...
by pyre on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @12:14PM
(#8227947)
> You're also susceptible to the defense that the PayPal dispute was a negotiation and settlement of the purchase price.
Sounds like (e.g.):
1) Contract is for $10K.
2) Client pays $4K.
3) Client stops paying.
4) Client issues chargeback for $4K.
5) PayPal dispute resolution recovers $2K of the $4K chargeback.
It's possible to claim that the PayPal dispute was a settlement of the purchase price, but it seems like it would be a stretch if that actually flies in court. I doubt that the PayPal dispute resolution covered the remaining $6K that was due, rather than just the dispute over the $4K that was already paid.
Sounds like (e.g.):
1) Contract is for $10K.
2) Client pays $4K.
3) Client stops paying.
4) Client issues chargeback for $4K.
5) PayPal dispute resolution recovers $2K of the $4K chargeback.
It's possible to claim that the PayPal dispute was a settlement of the purchase price, but it seems like it would be a stretch if that actually flies in court. I doubt that the PayPal dispute resolution covered the remaining $6K that was due, rather than just the dispute over the $4K that was already paid.