My main point, though, is this: What is your better alternative? Everybody's got criticisms of capitalism (me included), but as a broad organizing pattern for society, what is your alternative? How has that alternative actually worked when it's been tried? Is there real-world experience, or just theory?
I don't know what will replace Capitalism, or even what shape it'll take. As you say, flawed alternatives have been attempted -- and some were better at particular aspects, and some even forced Capitalism to take its current form in order not to perish. So you could argue modern day Capitalism owes its shape at least partly to competing systems.
In this case, we haven't made any inroads in deciding about the relative merits of Capitalism, Socialism or any other -isms, since there haven't been any nations that implemented them. Not truly.
I don't know about you, but it seems like a fruitless viewpoint. I believe Capitalism as practiced in the real world has run its course. This, of course, doesn't mean it's going to go in the next few decades, but I believe its days are counted. Call it optimism.
But you're nitpicking. The central of my comment is that you absolutely cannot assert that Capitalism is "objectively" better than every other system. Objectively better at what? By whose objective measurements?
How do you measure happiness of the population, self-fulfilment, solidarity, sustainability, etc?
Capitalism has run its course in my very subjective opinion. Hopefully there will be a successor that is more sustainable and people friendly, and hopefully it won't involve the invisible hand of the free market, state enforced monopolies, laissez faire or unsustainable consumerism.