Minecraft itself was a clone of the game "infiniminer". Whose developer had given up and stopped work after the source code was stolen.
When I think of the rise of Minecraft I am drawn to a few things he did differently.
1) He set up a way for customers to pay him for the game early (as soon as he had a minimum viable product). This gave him tons of feedback, money to keep working, and incentive to keep going because people were constantly asking him for features and tweaks.
2) He employed a simple and fun mechanic that allowed users to create their own things in the game (forts castles etc).
3) all of the content is procedurally generated. So every time you play it you get a different experience to some extent.
4) From very early on you would get weekly updates pushed out constantly adding new features. For most people new things were being added far faster than they could get bored with them.
5) it ran everywhere.
6) He didn't focus on graphics. He made design choices that would drastically simplify development at the expense of quality and/or performance. This lent itself to a blocky 'style' that was both easy to handle and visually unique.
What do you guys think? am I missing anything?
This one is widely considered to be false. There have been numerous catastrophic overhauls of many of Minecraft's sub-systems because they are very poorly designed, leading to stalled overhauls and whatnot. The architecture of systems was definitely not Notch's strong suit. That he chose an easy way to structure the world is only one of many design choices.
* Everything is forced into a cube
* No dynamic lighting
* No Shaders
* 16x16 Textures
* Water/lava is not volumetric
* No AI
* He used Java
* barely any physics (removing the bottom segment of a tree does not make the top fall down)
and on and on and on.
That "taste" wouldn't necessarily translate to the nitty-gritty game design skills necessary for a complex strategy, card, or board game, for example. But hey, it's enough. Not all of us can be Reiner Knizia.