News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Should a 4 Year Old Know? (2010) by jerf on Monday August 25, 2014 @09:20AM (#8221607)
And yet, it's one of the few solid results science has given us on the topic of children off to a good intellectual start. The signal is fairly strong.
Re:What Should a 4 Year Old Know? (2010) by mseebach on Monday August 25, 2014 @09:31AM (#8221635)
Does this science control for "being the kind of parent who thinks sitting down and reading with their kid is a pretty damn good idea"? I could see how reading to children is an effect of a set of values that are conductive to raising successful children, and as values often do, don't lend themselves well to being broken down into its constituent parts.

Or put in a different way - if you, as a parent, consider reading to your child a chore, will it still work?

Re:What Should a 4 Year Old Know? (2010) by Retric on Monday August 25, 2014 @10:45AM (#8221969)
Yes, language exposure in an of it's self is useful. Also, reading interesting books often leads to children continuing to read that same book to see how it ends. And thus reading for fun which provides a lot of useful practice.
Re:What Should a 4 Year Old Know? (2010) by mseebach on Monday August 25, 2014 @02:14PM (#8223110)
There's got to be something more than language on it's own. Surely, you can't just leave your kid with an audiobook - or the TV on.
Re:What Should a 4 Year Old Know? (2010) by watwut on Monday August 25, 2014 @10:02AM (#8221745)
There is whole lot of what we do not know about kids and effects of reading at various ages. There are also a lot of unconfirmed myths about it. To make it even worst, most studies on very young kids (babies) dealt with language deprived kids and not normally developing kids.

You will not be academically successful if you can not read well and reading a lot of books makes you better reader. Parents who love reading and read a lot lead to kids that love reading.

Depending on what exactly you mean as good intellectual start, the effects might been much less proven then we like to believe.

Re:What Should a 4 Year Old Know? (2010) by jerf on Monday August 25, 2014 @11:42AM (#8222244)
You know, I'm actually first on board with the idea that rather a lot of science is more poorly sourced than we'd like, and a lot of people place too much trust in "Science!". There's a lot of people who use the religion part of their brain to deal with "Science!".

On the other hand, this pathological need to disprove every study that has ever come out, ever, on every topic ever, is equally wrong. Perhaps it is also sourced from the same part of the brain.

Simply demanding more proof than we have right now is too powerful an argument; it disproves everything, and is thus useless. This may not be the all-singing, all-dancing result that is so easy to call for when it's not your job to provide it, but it is one of the few strong signals we legitimately have about early intellectual development, and it's as wrong to just dismiss it as it is to blindly trust it.

To forever demand higher standards is not sophisticated; it is to embrace endless, profound, uncorrectable ignorance. It is not scientific.

Re:What Should a 4 Year Old Know? (2010) by watwut on Monday August 25, 2014 @01:21PM (#8222744)
I'm not disproving those studies, just their interpretations. Those famous baby reading studies were made on language deprived children, because it actually makes sense. Those babies are in need of help. Knowing whether twenty or whatever minutes of reading makes difference or not can change peoples lives. It turns out, that it does.

However, concluding from the above that normally developing baby in family that communicates with him a lot will get the same benefit is incorrect. May or may not be.

The other thing is, babies, toddlers, preschoolers and elementary school children are very different in a lot of ways. The effects of reading on those groups are going to be different. The effects of reading on interested and uninterested child are going to be different too. And it just so happens that many very small kids are not interested in being read to.

Note that I'm not saying that reading to preschooler stories that the preschooler likes will not help to build love for reading. I'm kinda sure it will. However, the whole "reading every day is necessary for children of all ages" drum beats are overstating what is actually known about it.