Re:Show HN: Scottish Independence Referendum Heatmap
by tlarkworthy on Monday August 25, 2014 @08:40AM
(#8221494)
The kernel size (smoothing width) should be chosen based on something like leave-on-out cross validation. At the moment the sampling is too sparse and everything is independent and not smooth at all.
This is described in the intro of "Assessment of probability density estimation methods: Parzen window and Finite Gaussian Mixtures"
http://www0.cs.ucl.ac.uk/staff/c.archambeau/publ/iscas_aa06....
(as well as many other places that just happened to be the first google result)
email me if you want more details, I am ex-informatics.
Re:Show HN: Scottish Independence Referendum Heatmap
by chriswait on Monday August 25, 2014 @09:28AM
(#8221627)
This is massively useful, I was looking for a way to 'aggregate' results somewhat. I will read through this today and might send you a question or two later on if you don't mind.
Re:Show HN: Scottish Independence Referendum Heatmap
by tlarkworthy on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @10:57AM
(#8232438)
Yeah send any queries over or I can go through it face to face if you want.
Re:Show HN: Scottish Independence Referendum Heatmap
by wambotron on Monday August 25, 2014 @10:17AM
(#8221804)
This is interesting, but I feel like I have no real knowledge of the situation to give a good vote. I voted 'yes' as I assumed, after looking at the map, that most Scots want it.
It doesn't matter to me, though. I'm not Scottish!
Re:Show HN: Scottish Independence Referendum Heatmap
by smcl on Monday August 25, 2014 @11:30AM
(#8222194)
Interestingly "Scottish"ness doesn't necessarily matter for eligibility to vote in this referendum. I was born and raised there for 25 years but cannot vote as I'm not resident there. Those who live in Scotland can vote, regardless* of their nationality or how they identify. Which is of course correct and reflects what I'd like an independent Scotland to look like - immigrant friendly and diverse.
* = within certain restrictions, something like a couple of years resident prior to the referendum. Don't quote me on that :)
We're using it to collect and heatmap yes/no opinions, worldwide, for the Scottish Independence Referendum next month. We'd love to know how you feel, and I'm particularly interested in any feedback you can give me on performance or UX.