News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Example of Forensic Science at Its Worst: US v. Brig. ... by rayiner on Sunday August 24, 2014 @10:58AM (#8218699)
What this really highlights is that lay people trust computer forensics people to be experts, and often that trust is misplaced. Unfortunately, this isn't the only example of misplaced trust. In several places, Zdziarski laments that computer forensics doesn't live up to the standards of proper "science." Yet, his trust in the rest of forensic "science" is also misplaced. Pretty much everything besides DNA forensics, maybe fingerprints, is junk: http://lst.law.asu.edu/FS09/pdfs/Koehler4_3.pdf (page 4).

Indeed, the National Science Foundation has been looking into the field and has been shocked by how unfounded it is: http://www.nsf.gov/pubs/2013/nsf13120/nsf13120.jsp ("While the report acknowledges that 'the forensic science disciplines have produced valuable evidence that has contributed to the successful prosecution and conviction of criminals as well as to the exoneration of innocent people,' it cites a need for systematic research to validate the various disciplines’ underlying assumptions and methodologies, adding that the 'forensic science ... communities will be improved by opportunities to collaborate with the broader science and engineering communities.')

All that is just a polite way of saying: "holy shit your techniques lack real scientific foundations; you guys need to hire real scientists."

Re:An Example of Forensic Science at Its Worst: US v. Brig. ... by Zigurd on Sunday August 24, 2014 @11:56AM (#8218830)
On top of the junky aspects of forensic "science" are many bad practices. 1600+ cases in Massachusetts were called into question due to a crime lab employee who told police and prosecutors what they wanted to hear. She was a hero until she wasn't.

She was convicted of a crime and got a short prison term. The investigation found she "acted alone."

Is she an outlier?