I suggest you try reading Econ101 more clearly before citing it to make such dangerous propositions as removing labor regulations.
It's similar to the situation of a hypothetical (or not so hypothetical really) society which decided to "help out" potato farmers by limiting the price of a kg of potatoes to $10. What would you expect? Potato production would skyrocket as people try and cash in on the boom, while potato buying would plummet as people switch to unregulated alternatives.
Imagine this situation continuing on, with more and more vegetables becoming price-controlled, all the while as the mass of unemployed farmers grows and grows (because the system supports people in their failure to be vegetable farmers with unemployment handouts), the conditions of the market become worse and worse, and the further distortionary actions (for example, police crackdowns on blackmarket vegetable sales) required to sustain the whole system become more and more extreme. When someone questions the need for the price restrictions, the average citizen responds:
"Vegetable markets would not magically become free markets (in the textbook-definition sense) if there were no regulations. People are forced to grow vegetables, there aren't enough buyers per grower to make the demand high enough to make the market fluid, and a single buyer can influence the price."
Of course, this really isn't hypothesis. Citizens of today's socialised, regulated countries are just blind to the destructive consequences which surround them.
Look at what happened with the no-negotiation agreements between Apple and co. in Silicon Valley. This was for some high-wage people, so we're not talking about a wage floor issue here.
Yet those agreements stil happened , because a single company can influence wages. In a true free market, there are so many buyers and sellers that no single actor can influence the price.
Not to mention that on a more theoretical level, there is a lower bound on the amount of money people need to live, so there _is_ a lower bound on wages, or at least a lower bound on wages. This is also a pretty good argument for basic income, because it would make participation really voluntary.
...blah...minimum labor conditions...free education
I think you've got that one backwards. Said cows will spread to China rather than falling. It's not sacred entitlement, just a practical choice of what regulations to pass and what to spend tax receipts on.
And the argument about socialised services being more efficient definitely needs a citation.
The reason they can go to the ER is because the ER has to treat you if your case is life-threatening. They then proceed to not pay the resulting bill, get taken to collections, and file for bankruptcy, which has the effect of giving them free medical treatment.
Only it wasn't free preventative care, or a free doctor's visit. It was a free visit to the ER and free inpatient treatment. Guess which is more expensive, a doctor's visit or a visit to the ER?
Given that you, the person with money, end up footing the bill either way, would you prefer the less expensive or the more expensive option?
When you go to the ER without insurance, you get patched up and kicked out ASAP. This creates other complications... People can't work, they seek out social services, etc. So you have a situation where a chronic condition that you could manage for $4,000 a year costs exponentially more when you price in food stamps, disability payments, temporary assistance payments and other programs.
If your main concern is cost, empirically socialised systems cost less and generate better results.
http://media.economist.com/images/20090627/CBB677.gif
Unfortunately it's impossible to make a proper comparison since essentially all developed nations except for the USA have adopted some sort of socialized medicine or (i.e. Switzerland) an extremely regulated private system. So USA has essentially been alone in its experiment towards private healthcare.
Given that the one system which is much more privatized than the rest has had such poor efficency outcomes I would say that the burden of proof is on anyone who would claim that privatizing even more wouldn't just make the problem worse.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_heal...
Like I said, you can start with Econ 101, and work your way up from there. I don't know why they don't just give it a try. It's more fun to be open-minded than think you know everything already.
To me it is a shame to see people so stubborn and resistant to thinking differently.
Many different economic systems have been tried all across the world and throughout history. Given all of your reading, surely you could point to an example of these theories being tried out in a real economy and succeeding?
As far as I know, there are no successes. Most attempts couldn't have open borders, because everyone would leave.
(And yes, there are lots of other factors, like corruption and the natural resource curse.)
Essentially, claiming that your economic theory will only work once a dramatic, complete, state-wide change as occured is a non-starter. Nations advance by degrees, and if there aren't small moves that can be made towards the goal that provide evidence that the theory is sound, it would be foolish to believe that big moves will fair any better.
I would genuinely like to see examples of where libertarianism ideals have been tried on a small to medium scale and been successful. And if there aren't any, same question as to jasonisalive: why is there such confidence among libertarians that it works in the real world?
To me it seems that only you talk about libertarians, while jasonisalive talked about generic economic research.
(Wikipedia confirms my belief that libertarians are quite heterogeneous and it is more of a political philosophy/ideology than about economy anyway.)
Subjects based on complex data sets without possibility of experiments are hard to verify for people external to the subject. (Famous other cases are climate science and evolution.)
From that, left wing extremists (I don't know anything about your position -- you might argue against "free market", which was the subject here or "libertarians" which you mention?) sometimes write conspiracy theories that all the academics in economy are idiots and/or in a conspiracy.
So let us skip this and instead look at practical results:
If you have a country with low corruption, competent state administration and a capitalist system you might get a good economic development. Otherwise, you will not.
Anyway, the West doesn't need to respond to the threat of China and others (Korea for instance) by aping the worst aspects of these countries. True economic liberalisation will pose a far more effective and constructive counter.
The difference between us is that what I propose has never been properly implemented and tested, while social democracy has, extensively. How you could make claims about the relative productivity of these two systems with the vacuum of test data is beyond me.
Anyway, I've made my claim, and I stand by it. I'm confident that eventually people will see the merits of it, even if it does take some thinking. In the short term it really doesn't matter if people disagree with me. We'll see how things stand in 50 years or so.
So, given that this theory has never been tested, why are you so confident in it? So confident, in fact, that you imagine everyone else in this thread to be completely ignorant of basic economics, or driven by ideological groupthink?
1) Knowing better/attempting to overrule the free market (minimum wages, minimum labour conditions, centralised permits to sell goods such as drugs, medical services, legal services)
2) Giving "something for nothing" (subsidised/free education, subsidised/free healthcare, subsidised/free pensions/saving schemes.
Currently anyone who dares to question these aspects of Western economies is immediately eviscerated by the crowd. The culture of entitlement is very strong. Soon enough, however, with the last of the props that sustained these sick economies thus far failing (militarism, centralised currency control, controls on global mobility, global cultural allure), getting rid of them will be hailed as bold new thinking.