Re:Chromecast Rooted
by higherpurpose on Sunday August 24, 2014 @07:49AM
(#8218325)
They could also decide to allow their devices to be unlocked in a secure way, instead of us having to rely on vulnerabilities, and then them having to fix them.
Re:Chromecast Rooted
by thethimble on Sunday August 24, 2014 @11:41PM
(#8220506)
Devil's advocate: perhaps Google is taking a loss on the $35 device in exchange for user lock-in? I doubt the immense R&D behind building it would have been worth it otherwise.
I'm not arguing against unlimited freedom - just arguing against the expectation of unlimited freedom when all things are considered.
Re:Chromecast Rooted
by TazeTSchnitzel on Saturday August 23, 2014 @09:29PM
(#8217373)
I'd say users choose convenience over freedom, the security is in the back of their minds. Make a more convenient but free phone and people will use it.
This. I'd say they care about freedom more-less as much as about security, i.e. not at all. They just choose more convenient over less convenient. And honestly, it's perfectly understandable.
Re:Chromecast Rooted
by userbinator on Sunday August 24, 2014 @07:22AM
(#8218281)
Convenience is a big part of it, but I don't see freedom being marketed quite as much (if at all) as security - these days, the new version of a product almost always mentions "more secure" in its list of features, while "more freedom", when it appears, seems to read more like "you can now do new things with your device that you couldn't before", than "you can have more control over it."
Normally, vulnerabilities would be considered a bad thing. Heartbleed is a great example of that. But in cases like these, it's a very good thing. This is why I always like to remind those whose goal is to build more secure systems to consider the implications of their work, lest our devices become even more secure against us. They usually have in mind a world where everyone has full control of their devices which are then highly secure against attacks by others, and that's a good thing; but I think it's far more likely to turn into one where corporations have all the control and devices are secure against their owners, especially as typical users continue to choose security over freedom.