Again, we agree that it is enormously complex, I am lamenting the fact that we don't put more resources into the psychological aspect of it.
That is, what you are asking for is a study that would show why large populations of people can't just "eat less." Why are they stuck in a rut of eating more than they need? Worse, why are many of them not even happy about it, but still can't get out?
This hypothesis is basically that that behavior is fueled by a feedback cycle that has, in large part, the actual foods that people eat caught in it somewhere.
Now, I think I see what you are getting at. Could you fix this at other parts of the feedback cycle? Perhaps. And I certainly agree that should get research, too. I just don't think this research is unrelated.
That is absolutely not the point of Taubes's research. Reread the article.
That is, if this singles out some food as more likely to cause overeating/fat gain, that will still be an incomplete explanation. Which is where the psychology aspect would step up.
Right?
I disagree, the study would be completely different. This study is studying the acute effects of diet on the body, specifically trying to determine if macronutrient composition has an effect on weight loss, given equal calories.
The study I'm talking about would deal with long term behavioral aspects of dieting, and would look for people who had long term success with dieting and see what they are eating. Or maybe there would be some other study design, but it certainly wouldn't be like the one they are doing now, which completely controls diet thus eliminating the compliance aspect.
The reason I think this distinction is so important is because of the amount of energy being consumed by the scientific community around debating the question of whether or not macronutrient composition has a direct effect on weight loss. Even if the people who feel like macronutrient composition has a direct impact on weight loss are right, the effect is not very dramatic.
It would be much more fruitful to study the psychological impact of specific diets, and whether or not they are likely to impact over eating, which is the one and only cause of obesity, as you mentioned.
Though, I do have to cede the point that a proper study of this sort would be different.
That's absolutely right.
"takes what is a relatively simple issue and makes it needlessly complex."
Human metabolism and psychology is complex. Basically, it's the most complex system that we know of.
You can't just throw out psychology and metabolism, and say it doesn't matter, because as long as you eat less calories than you consume you're alright.
People have know "calories in vs. calories out" for decades. People are still getting fatter. Maybe if you shout it a bit louder, it will start working? Sorry about the sarcasm, but that's how I feel about the issue.
I feel it's a bit like telling a depressed person to just "stop it". Snap out of it! Why are you thinking these bad thoughts? It's bad for you! Stop it!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ow0lr63y4Mw
You do touch on this though "(how to ensure someone sticks with the program)", but then seem to gloss over it. You start out saying it's "not complex". If it's not complicated, why is it not solved yet?
What you eat, is certainly not everything, but sugar drives behaviour very strongly. More so than other nutrients is my impression. It affects motivation which again affects how well you stick with a program. It's not everything, but it's part of the puzzle. Other things that affect compliance could be, mental health, friends, advertisement, culture, economical situation.. How is this not complicated?