Re:The Best Way To Improve Your Creativity
by xsmasher on Monday September 14, 2009 @02:52AM
(#821231)
Are you saying the difference between the performance of the two groups wasn't statistically significant, or that their methodology is flawed, or that their results were not reproduced in other studies?
It's possible that their theory is bullshit, but it seems like you're discounting the data it is based on without cause.
Re:The Best Way To Improve Your Creativity
by nopassrecover on Monday September 14, 2009 @06:59AM
(#821446)
He is saying that in one single test of two groups, one of the teams has to win. Deciding that they won because of 'x' after the fact is not science.
They decided to see if X would help one team win before they collected results.
Re:The Best Way To Improve Your Creativity
by nopassrecover on Monday September 14, 2009 @08:19AM
(#821508)
Oh okay I missed that. I still question the statistical significance of a single experiment. Still interesting though.
Re:The Best Way To Improve Your Creativity
by roundsquare on Monday September 14, 2009 @08:18AM
(#821505)
I usually assume that SciAm does a decent job of making sure they print credible articles. So I would generally assume that the experimental design was good.
Sheer tripe. Out of two groups, one is going to do better. If the first group had just happened to do better, we'd be reading an article about how thinking something is "close" makes it more "concrete" and raises your creativity, because it's easier to think of things that are tangible -- or whatever other Just-So story they'd invent. The second group didn't have its creativity "raised"; it just happened to be the group that won the coin flip.