Touche! To be fair, it's not just a fashion statement, though -- it's also a matter of branding.
... improved design, for example one which replaces the subtle "get started with Tarsnap" link with an attractive 200x60 button...
Good idea. One question comes to mind, though: Is increasing the attractiveness of signup links as effective for commercial services as it is for free account-creation? I don't dispute that it would help -- I just wonder if it would give me a large number of new accounts but only a far smaller number of new paying users. (Only one way to find out for certain, of course...)
If you don't have the time, skill, or desire to do this, there is an Internet full of starving web designers out there.
I have a few friends who are interested in graphics and web design, so I'll throw this in their direction and see what they can come up with -- at least now I have a basic structure for the content to get started with.
Thanks for the advice!
If you A/B test that against any improved design, for example one which replaces the subtle "get started with Tarsnap" link with an attractive 200x60 button, the graphical alternative will annihilate the performance of your minimalist alternative.
If you don't have the time, skill, or desire to do this, there is an Internet full of starving web designers out there. I got my current website design from a nice young lady in India for $150. With the degree of improvement you'll see, that would probably pay itself back within a few days to a week.