News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please review the new tarsnap website by gjm11 on Sunday September 13, 2009 @09:02PM (#820871)
(Most of the following consists of niggles. This will give the impression that I think worse of the site than I actually do. Sorry.)

The message sent by the design has changed from "Absolutely no effort has gone into designing this; I have other priorities" (see also, e.g., Craigslist, Drudge Report, useit.com) to "I thought this could do with a bit of thought about design, so I sat down for half an hour and hacked together a style sheet". This may or may not be an improvement.

Purely superficial visual-stylistic remarks (important note: I am not a graphic designer or anything; and I've looked at your pages using exactly one web browser on exactly one machine):

I think there are too many rules (mostly box borders), which are too prominent and too close to one another and to the text. And, generally, not enough whitespace.

I tried moving the boxes about 1em further apart, putting the text within the boxes a uniform 1em from the edges, and changing the borders from #000 to #999 (and #ccc for the rule between the box header and the main content) and I think it was a definite improvement. They still look, well, awfully boxy, but changing that would mean a pile more work.

The hover highlighting for your navigation sidebar would be greatly improved, I think, by changing the background (e.g., to the same as for a.current -- that "doesn't work" for the link representing the current page, but that may be a feature rather than a bug) instead of adding a border.

The majority of commercial websites seem to use sans-serif faces for most of their text. I like serifs :-), but there is something to the argument that they don't work well on the crappy low-resolution monitors we all have to put up with and you might find that, say, adding font-family: sans-serif and (something like) line-height: 140% to div.box gives a more "professional" look. You may or may not care about this. For some reason, I find that reducing the contrast just a bit (color: #333; you wouldn't want this for the headings) also has this effect. This may all just be because any change away from default settings produces the impression that more effort has gone into the design, or something.

Marginally less superficial comments:

On the About page, you should probably make "portsnap" and "FreeBSD Update" into links.

In addition to not being a graphic designer, I am also not a lawyer; but I wonder whether your legal page needs to say explicitly that the "Why?"s aren't part of the legal agreement.

Too many parentheses on the "Utility" page.

On the why-picodollars page, you probably mean 2^-40, not 2^(-30).

On the why-10^9 page, you claim that nothing other than RAM is addressed in hardware. This is, of course, not true. You might consider replacing "RAM" with "memory", or something.

On the scrypt page, PBKDF2 and bcrypt should be links.

It's a pity that the Why? links bounce the user to a new page. (Especially on the accounts page, which has forms on it.) You might consider some AJAXy nonsense to avoid this, but it's probably about ten times more trouble than it's worth.

Re:Please review the new tarsnap website by cperciva on Monday September 14, 2009 @01:09AM (#821125)
"I thought this could do with a bit of thought about design, so I sat down for half an hour and hacked together a style sheet". This may or may not be an improvement.

Ouch! Thanks for the honesty, though. :-)

I tried moving the boxes about 1em further apart

I'll meet you half-way -- a 2em gap looks too big to my eye, but I like 1.5em more than the original 1em.

putting the text within the boxes a uniform 1em from the edges

Oops! I didn't realize that this wasn't uniform.

changing the borders from #000 to #999 (and #ccc for the rule between the box header and the main content)

That looks a bit too weak to my eye, but I agree on the principle -- I've dropped them to #555 and #aaa.

The hover highlighting [...]

I spent an obscene amount of time trying to decide what I wanted to do there -- changing the background was the first idea I had, but I couldn't get it to look a way I liked. I think I'll have to come back to this once I've gotten away from looking at that menu for a while.

...sans-serif faces...

Sigh. I hate the idea of specifying fonts in web pages... why can't web browsers just pick a reasonable default? But you're right, it does look much better with sans-serif -- consider it changed.

... reducing the contrast just a bit...

Lowered contrast helps readability, but I hate the look of grey text (maybe this is just a personal thing -- but I'd like to be able to look at my website without wincing), so I've done this using an off-white background instead.

On the About page, you should probably make "portsnap" and "FreeBSD Update" into links.

I considered that, but there's nothing sensible to make them link to -- I have pages about portsnap and FreeBSD Update on my personal site, but they are several years out of date.

I wonder whether your legal page needs to say explicitly that the "Why?"s aren't part of the legal agreement.

My law student friends tell me that this isn't a problem; and it doesn't matter anyway since I really don't care if the explanations are somehow interpreted as part of the terms.

Too many parentheses on the "Utility" page.

Good point, I didn't realize how many parenthetical remarks I was making when I wrote that text.

On the why-picodollars page, you probably mean 2^-40, not 2^(-30).

Oops!

On the why-10^9 page, you claim that nothing other than RAM is addressed in hardware. This is, of course, not true. You might consider replacing "RAM" with "memory", or something.

Is it not true? I can't think of any non-random access memory which is addressed in the same way as RAM is.

On the scrypt page, PBKDF2 and bcrypt should be links.

Good idea.

It's a pity that the Why? links bounce the user to a new page.

Those links should be opening up in a new window -- aren't they? That's what happens in my web browser, but it's entirely possible that I did something non-portable.

Thanks for all the excellent suggestions -- this is exactly the sort of comment I was hoping to get here. I'm not necessarily going to follow all of your suggestions, but even those I'm not following have provided very useful food for thought.

Re:Please review the new tarsnap website by gjm11 on Monday September 14, 2009 @06:08AM (#821408)
non-random access memory: I suppose it depends on how you define "RAM". To almost everyone (even in your target audience, I think) "RAM" doesn't mean "any randomly-accessed memory", it means something like "fast writeable randomly-accessed memory whose vendors call it RAM". For instance, mask ROM would not generally be called RAM, even though it's addressed in hardware and commonly comes in power-of-2 sizes.

should be opening up in a new window: ah, I see. I've got so firmly into the habit of middle-clicking such links that I didn't even try left-clicking :-). (Which, yes, means that if you make them do fancy AJAX stuff then I will lose out...)

Re:Please review the new tarsnap website by jfarmer on Monday September 14, 2009 @02:03AM (#821185)
You probably already think I'm an asshole, but even though it's fun to tweak a design until it's "just right," none of these changes will have a big impact on your bottom line.

1em versus 1.5 vs 2em? That's premature optimization.

And statements like "[l]owered contrast helps readability, but I hate the look of grey text" tell me you're designing for yourself, not for your customer.

That's fine, if that's what you're doing, but I've been assuming the opposite, viz., that your goal is to increase the number of people who pay for tarsnap.

Re:Please review the new tarsnap website by cperciva on Monday September 14, 2009 @02:12AM (#821190)
you're designing for yourself, not for your customer

Not quite. In the absence of hard evidence either way (yes, I know, A/B testing -- but there isn't enough traffic on the tarsnap website right now to get any statistical significance for minor changes) website design is purely a matter of taste... and if it's going to be a matter of taste, why not go with mine?

Re:Please review the new tarsnap website by jfarmer on Monday September 14, 2009 @02:45AM (#821221)
Because you aren't your customer.

And what you said isn't true, although most engineers I know believe it. It's not A/B testing or bust, and design isn't series of arbitrary aesthetic decisions.

You can also gather (non-numerical) data by going out and talking to potential customers, figuring out exactly what they need, and then making design decisions with that as an input.

Re:Please review the new tarsnap website by dagw on Monday September 14, 2009 @07:44AM (#821479)
website design is purely a matter of taste

That's not entirely true. Design and typography pros have over the centuries developed a series of rules and guidelines for what constitutes good and usable design. These have generally proven to be fairly universal and are more than simply a matter of taste.