News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by brazzy on Sunday September 13, 2009 @06:13PM (#820660)
Peak oil doesn't mean that all oil will suddenly be gone. It just means that constantly increasing demand cannot be satsfied forever. For well over a century, the rate of oil production and consumption has increased very quickly. It's physically impossible for this development to continue indefinitely, and no amount of hand-waving can change that.

New discoveries don't change that - you'd need more new discoveries each year than the year before (which is the opposite of what is actually happening). Oil sands don't change that - they don't just require more capital, but also more energy to use - and energy is exactly what you're trying to produce after all. Eventually we'll have to expend the equivalent 1 barrel of oil to mine and refine 2 barrels worth of oil sands.

Peak oil doesn't mean no more oil tomorrow. Oil production may well continue for a century or more - it will just keep decreasing, not increasing. When this starts happening is a matter of debates, research and numbers. There are strong indications that we are seeing it happen right now: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Hubbert_world_2004.png (look at the source - these are not made-up numbers)

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by joe_the_user on Sunday September 13, 2009 @09:46PM (#820923)
Wikipedia is not the best source. Not necessarily the worst either but still.

The phrase "Peak Oil" has become much more than a statement that at some point in time the human production of oil will. For example, one of the primary boosters of the phrase was the website "Dieoff.org" which anticipates the death of most people on the planet. And you've demonstrated this yourself by jumping to the Hubbert curve...

The thing about a Hubbert curve is that it is base on regional data. Production in various regions has, rather roughly, indeed expand exponentially and then gone down exponentially. But where this behavior has been roughly seen, the exponential decline has happened because the particular sources have been replaced by cheaper sources elsewhere. Since this cannot happen on a world scale, there is every reason to expect world-scale production on existing fields to go down gradually rather than exponentially. Further, as the GP notes, more oil is being discovered even into the declining range.

This relatively slow decline will provide some impetus for alternative energy sources - it already has to an extent.

The world has quite a few problems but approach that our "Peak Oil" friends use for framing these problems is not useful.

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by brazzy on Monday September 14, 2009 @04:28AM (#821326)
As I wrote, the Wikipedia link refers to a source - which is a report from the US government.

The cheapest and most efficient sources have already been found. They're in the middle east, and many of them have recently reached the point where production is declining despite all technical efforts. And those efforts to sustain a very high production rate from a diminishing source mean that the decline could indeed become quite steep.

As for new discoveries, the problem is that they, too, are declining (and have done so for over 2 decades).

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by netsp on Sunday September 13, 2009 @08:15PM (#820801)
That is true. Oil production doesn't even need to drop off very fast to produce drastic effects. The reason peak oil is taken so seriously is because of inelastic demand. Regardless of the cost of oil, we consume it in roughly equal amounts. This means that a small drop off in the production of oil could lead to incredibly high prices.

The reason that is bad is the same reason that demand for oil is inelastic. The cost of not consuming oil is very high.

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by lsc on Sunday September 13, 2009 @06:54PM (#820695)
Oil is not the only source of energy. Granted, it is one of the most convenient, but one could use energy from a fission plant to extract oil sands, etc...

If you don't care about the environment, there are even easier solutions; processes for making gas out of coal have been around since before world war 2.

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by mr_eel on Sunday September 13, 2009 @08:21PM (#820815)
That doesn't make sense. If we use fission, why bother with the oil?

The real point here is not when we run out of oil, but rather when it becomes too inconvenient -- too costly in other words. Even with new finds, oil is becoming a more and more inconvenient source of energy. The reason it remains attractive is because of the infrastructure surrounding it's production, transport and use.

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by lsc on Sunday September 13, 2009 @08:37PM (#820838)
because it's easier to power a car with gas than with electricity. Like you said, the infrastructure is in place.
Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by lupin_sansei on Sunday September 13, 2009 @11:25PM (#821021)
> It's physically impossible for this development to continue indefinitely

Why can't oil be made synthetically? Say by genetically engineering bacteria etc. That being the case I don't see any limit to oil production

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by brazzy on Monday September 14, 2009 @04:20AM (#821315)
First law of thermodynamics. The whole point of oil is that it's energy-rich. To make it synthetically, you need to take energy from somewhere - but if you intend to use the oil to produce energy, why not use it directly instead of going through the intermediate oil stage.

Basically, synthetically-made oil only makes sense only if the process involves an efficient way to turn a widely-available but inferior form of energy into oil. Basically, that's bio-ethanol: already being done, but not feasible at the scale it would take to satisfy all current demand for oil-

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by lupin_sansei on Monday September 14, 2009 @05:27AM (#821374)
Oil is a convenient, efficient storage mechanism for energy, and there's a vast existing "user base" or machinery that runs on oil. If we use non-oil energy to provide heat and light in order to "grow" oil via some organic process we could still be ahead.
Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by crpatino on Monday September 14, 2009 @04:25AM (#821324)
This is possible of course. After all, the stuff we extract from the ground came into existence somehow in nature, and we know we are good at speeding up nature to do staff we want.

The two problems I see are scale and unwillingness.

On the one hand, the conventional wisdom say that the natural oil was made over millions and millions of years. Even if we manage to find a way to speed up nature 1000x we are in the thousands and thousands of years to regenerate the whole global reserve. At present consumption rates, know reserves will last less than 50 years. This means we would be better off developing alternate energies, reducing consumption, and reserving oil exclusively for strategic uses only (you cannot fly a plane without fossil fuels, but you can make your chairs of wood instead of plastic).

The other issue I see, and I belive there is no solution at all, is unwillingness from the politicians and the society in general to acknowledge the problem and do what needs to be done. Every child learns in the school that oil is a non renewable resource... and what we do? We consume more and more of the stuff every year. It is depressing to see the huge amount of utter garbage that gets made and sold out of oil, frivolous stuff, junk that nobody really loves or cares about...

Markets are slow to transfer information to economic actors when conditions change drastically. Lack of political organized response, we are in for very interesting times in the decades to come.

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by lupin_sansei on Monday September 14, 2009 @05:23AM (#821370)
> At present consumption rates, know reserves will last less than 50 years

But those reserves are growing not shrinking over time. In the 1950s there was only 10 years of known reserves. We need to start worrying when the known reserves start getting smaller, rather than growing over time.

http://www.scdigest.com/images/misc/World-Oil-Reserves_web_0...

http://www.cheaperpetrolparty.com/Images/World%20Crude%20Oil...

http://www.theoildrum.com/uploads/12/opec_reserve_growth.gif

> Markets are slow to transfer information to economic actors when conditions change drastically

Hardly. Prices rise and fall in minutes when there's new information.

Also if the 20th century has taught us anything it's that we need to keep politicans as far away from resource development as possible,

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by crpatino on Monday September 14, 2009 @04:15PM (#822514)
lupin, I think you are taking a really cheap shot at me. I am not arguing that we are about to run out of oil in the near future. I dont think oil will "run dry" in my lifetime, and quite possible not in my kids lifetime as well. So, let me restate my point.

Rebuild an artificial oil reserve of the size of our original natural oil reserve (at the late 19th century levels... regardless of the reserve was known or not), is not an achievable goal for the 21st century. We dont have the time to do the R&D and we dont have the resources to implement the project in the scale needed. Can we do the stuff, I think yes; but un a much lower scale and only for strategic applications that cannot use any other form of less concentrated energy. The rest of society will have to due without or find an alternative solution.

Now... >Hardly. Prices rise and fall in minutes when there's new information.

That is precisely the problem! Variation within minutes does not produce a consistent strategy, it produces noise. We are guiding the future of ourselves and our children on sheer noise. Not an improvement over the shaman who reads the burned scraps of the dinner.

In peak oil circles, it is a widely held belief that 2005 is the year of Peak Oil (since global oil production has plateaued over the last 5 years or so). I do not believe it is the Peak Oil. I believe we are observing a peak oil, resulting from underinvestment from the Big Oil industry in the 90's, when it was so cheap to bother and they decided to "focus on developing existing reserves". Fortunately, you cannot just declare that you are now exploiting new reserves. It takes both material and human infrastructure that takes time to implement. Thus, demand exceeds supply and you see a barrel rise up to almost $150 USD. This triggers a catalyst to structural problems in finance sector and you end up in recession... unable to command the resources needed to upgrade your infrastructure.

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by lupin_sansei on Monday September 14, 2009 @10:55PM (#823176)
No offence meant!

So here's the interesting thing, our known reserves today are bigger than they were in the 19th century and paradoxically are getting bigger every year even though we are using more and more oil. Until this situation ends there's no need to waste resources developing an alternative energy source (assuming the sole reason for doing so is to mitigate running out of oil). We are essentially running into oil rather than out of it.

Higher oil prices automatically command resources and people to direct their attention to oil production. This is why we never run out of any resource, as soon as the price rises people move into the field (in order to get higher wages/returns) to solve the problem.

Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by ncarlson on Sunday September 13, 2009 @11:52PM (#821048)
He's talking about development in terms of oil well depletion.
Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by lupin_sansei on Monday September 14, 2009 @12:37AM (#821091)
Sure, but why limit our oil sources to just oil wells?
Re:Earth may be constantly producing oil by joe_the_user on Monday September 14, 2009 @01:28AM (#821148)
Another interesting thing this peak oil/anti-peak oil debate shows to me is the difficulty of factoring secular and cyclical processes together.

Yes, oil production will peak at some point is the too terribly distant future, but no, the pattern of decreased oil consumption won't be the same as the patter of increased oil consumption because the factors generating the decline won't be the same as the factors that generated rise.